Speaker
1: |
Osaka,
the second biggest city in the world's second biggest economy. Each year, the
single Japanese city generates goods and services worth nearly $700 billion.
At first glance, Osaka seems as prosperous and powerful as ever, but peel
away the glitz and you can find Osaka and Japan's dirty little secret. A
legacy of government mismanagement and economy decay. |
Speaker
2: |
It
was a failure fundamentally of management of political leadership that took
us from a big blowout to a crisis of dimensions that we haven't seen for
seven or eight decades. |
Speaker
1: |
It's
5 a.m. in Kamagasaki, a short drive from the city
centre. Thousands of unemployed men have gathered in a vain search for work. Kamagasaki is a world away from the popular image of Japan.
Many of these men helped build Japan's wealth, or what's left of it. They
came here as day labourers for the construction industry, which one time work
was plentiful, but a decade of economic stagnation has taken its toll. |
Speaker
3: |
[foreign
language] |
Speaker
4: |
[foreign
language] |
Speaker
1: |
In
a nearby park, some of Osaka's 15,000 homeless cue for a free meal. It's the
only food some of them will get for several days. Volunteers do the work. The
government provides virtually nothing. The men speak of resignation. |
Speaker
5: |
[foreign
language] |
Speaker
1: |
Their
bitterness and shame is all too clear. |
Speaker
3: |
[foreign
language] |
Speaker
1: |
The
poverty and misery here, reflects the falling of Japan's past, but it's also
important of it's future. Many Japanese people
simply don't believe this problem exists, but they won't be able to ignore it
for much longer. It's going to get a lot worse. The Japanese economy is in
serious trouble, and the large part of the problem is the industry that once
employed many of these men, construction. Success of Japanese governments
have tried to revive the anaemic economy by pouring trillions of dollars into
public works. The tactic has backfired and its legacy is a nation that is now
being crushed under a mountain of debt, and a landscape littered with roads,
dams, and bridges that make no economy sense at all. |
|
In
a land full of white elephants, the biggest and widest is an hour's drive
from Osaka. The Akashi Bridge is the longest, tallest, most expensive and
most pointless suspension bridge ever built. |
Speaker
6: |
This
is one of the most wasteful examples [inaudible] in this country. Features
the most expensive type and they just they deal with the tunnel at the
entrance and they didn't have to dig the tunnel. Just all they have to do,
just go over the hill. They made that cost ever higher. |
Speaker
1: |
[Akio
Agawa] is one of Japan's leading experts on public
works. He says that despite all the yen and all the concrete that is being
poured into the bridge's construction, hardly anyone uses it. It's a bridge
to nowhere, linking Japan's main island, Honshu, with Shikoku, a much smaller
island with a shrinking population, described in guidebooks as a rural
backwater. What's even more remarkable though, is that there were already two
other bridges connecting the island. |
Speaker
6: |
Engineers
wanted just one bridge along this small [inaudible]. But there are three
pre-fixtures facing this in [inaudible], so people especially politicians and
business people wanted their own bridge, so there are now three. |
Speaker
1: |
The
men who built the bridge expected it to generate extra traffic, but all it's
done is take business away from the once thriving very industry. |
Speaker
7: |
[foreign
language] |
Speaker
1: |
Local
jobs have been lost and traffic has sparse, but there's an even bigger
problem weighing on this bridge. The authority that built it now has debts totaling four trillion yen. |
Speaker
2: |
They're
the most expensive concrete per square foot ever in humanity. They're on a
delusionary scale of the dimension of the pyramid. |
Speaker
1: |
The
bridge to nowhere is not the construction industry's only delusion. Japan has
been addicted to concrete for decades, and despite these tough economic times,
it refuses to kick the habit. Across the nation, massive tunnels are being
carved out of mountainsides where perfectly [inaudible] ones already exist.
Major freeways have been built between miner villages and river beds have
been concreted to make the water run better. |
Alex
Kerr: |
Depending
on how you calculate, we're close to 60% of the entire coastline lined with
concrete at this point. |
Speaker
1: |
Alex
Kerr has spent the last 30 years watching the countryside get concreted over.
He's written two best selling books on Japan's
fading beauty. Kerr points out that Japan now spends 30% more on public works
than America, Canada, Germany, France, Italy, and Britain combined. |
Alex
Kerr: |
That
means that Japan has essentially laid 30 times the amount of concrete per
square foot that America does in one year. |
Speaker
1: |
And
there are plans on the drawing board that make the Akashi Bridge look like a
drop in the ocean. |
Speaker
6: |
Our
latest national development programme embedded as new capital city and work
... |
Speaker
1: |
A
new capital city? |
Speaker
6: |
Yes,
new capital city at some place far away from Tokyo. While they argue that
Tokyo is too crowded and so they need a new capital. |
Speaker
1: |
After
the second World War, this frenzy of construction made perfect sense. But
these days, it's in no one's interest, except the politicians. |
Alex
Kerr: |
Traditionally,
a certain percentage, it's often said three percent of most government
construction projects, the money flows into the coffers through bribes and
paybacks and other ways of the political parties, so Japan's political
parties, all of them not just the LDP, are funded through construction. |
Speaker
1: |
The
people that reel the real power are in on the act too. There are 70,000 bureaucrats
working in the land and transport ministry. They control 80% of the public
work's budget. |
Alex
Kerr: |
One
of the sources of Japan's corruption is the fact that the bureaucracies of
Japan are allowed to profit from the businesses under their control. People
from the construction ministry, own some of the companies who build and
manage the dams, and who are given contracts with no bidding. Then after
retirement, they then are hired as Amakudari, that
expression that means 'drop from heaven.' Yes, so after retirement they're
then hired by construction firms. |
Speaker
1: |
This
iron triangle of bureaucrats, politicians, and business has pushed one of the
world's richest countries to the brink of financial ruin. Because of its
public work's spending, Japan now owes more money than any other country in
history. |
Speaker
6: |
National
government can't print money, so well yes but in Euro sense, this is a
private company. It's already bankrupt. |
Speaker
1: |
And
on the debts of public corporations, such as the one responsible for the
Akashi bridge and the amount of money owed becomes truly mountainous. The
problem is that the mountain of debt could explode at any time, and it's up
to this man to diffuse the situation. Prime Minster
Junichiro Koizumi is a rarity in Japanese politics. He's the first Japanese
leader to have a perm. The first to be divorced, and the first to render
school girls weak at the knees. But most significantly, he's the first to
declare war on the construction state. Koizumi has promised to cut Japan's
debt by slashing public work spending, even if that means taking on his own
political machine. |
Junichiro
K.: |
[foreign
language] |
Speaker
1: |
But
despite his huge populous support, the political forces aligned against him
are powerful, more powerful perhaps than the Prime Minister himself. |
Speaker
2: |
Current
prime minister has in a sense been like a breath of oxygen. At least he said,
"We've got to change course." Real issue is, is he going to be able
to do it. Does he have the power within his party to change course? That is
still at best a very moot point. |
Speaker
1: |
To
see just how moot, we travelled to Nagano, northwest of Tokyo. A popular
tourist destination, Nagano was host to the 1998 winter games. New venues, freeways
and train lines were built at massive cost. But now the stadium stand empty,
and the city has debts totalling more than $10 billion. In desperation,
Nagano has turned to its own version of Junichiro Koizumi, Yasuo Tanaka,
independent candidate, racy novelist, and media darling. During the campaign
Tanaka promised a new era of openness and has been true to his word, moving
his office to the ground floor and behind glass so that the public can see
him at work. |
Yasuo
Tanaka: |
It's
a very open minded, where [inaudible] this crystal room, so local people just
come here to the hall and see, "Oh, what kind of people talking with Mr.
Tanaka?" The newspaper will write tomorrow morning what kind of
discussion. How we're now been making Japanese democracy, I think. |
Speaker
1: |
Like
Koizumi, Tanaka is trying to take a wrecking ball to the construction
industry. Most controversially, the governor has pulled the plug on plans for
nine dams. |
Yasuo
Tanaka: |
It's
a very mountainous prefecture, so we have our letter of concrete dams and on
the other side and now our prefectural we have very [tragedical]
130600 billion yen of debt. It's a debt. |
Speaker
1: |
High
up in the mountains that surround Nagano, is a piece of land that has been
untouched by the construction industry until now. |
Speaker
11: |
[foreign
language] |
Speaker
1: |
[inaudible]
is anti dam activist and strong supporter of
Governor Tanaka. He's researched the devastating impact construction would
have on the environment, and the fact that scientists say the ground here is
not stable. The dam supporters say it's necessary to prevent a once in a
hundred years flood, even though the river itself is hardly a raging torrent. |
Speaker
11: |
[foreign
language] |
Speaker
1: |
Tanaka
might be a hero with the public, but his decision has put him at odds with
the shadowing men who run Japan's construction state. [Tamatzu
Shimazaki] is one of Tanaka's fiercest critics in
the local assembly. He also happens to run a construction company. |
Tamatzu S.: |
[foreign
language] |
Yasuo
Tanaka: |
[foreign
language] |
Speaker
1: |
Governor
Tanaka doesn't have the numbers on the local assembly and his enemies have
put the dam back on the agenda. |
Alex
Kerr: |
In
Nagano, they've basically lost the battle. The local prefectural councilman
and the construction ministry itself, the actual bureaucrats of the central
ministry have joined hand in hand to fight this thing, and it pretty well
succeeded, because the governor cannot move without the support of the
prefectural council. |
Speaker
1: |
Junichiro
Koizumi is preparing for a similar battle with the iron triangle, and the
stakes are even higher. The economy is contracting, confidence is winding,
and the stock market keeps sliding. It's shed one quarter of its value since
the prime minister took over. |
Speaker
2: |
To
get to where we have to be, Prime Minster is going to have to break some of
the alliances that brought him to power, and make alliances with people who
are on the other side of the aisle. If he can do that, while keeping a
position as a majority prime minister, and then push through these reforms,
Japan has a chance to pull this off without a real implosion. But this is
really the last chance. It's five minutes to midnight and the clock is
ticking. |
Speaker
1: |
The
problem has become so serious that no matter what road Japan takes, many more
people will end up in places like Kamagasaki, if
the government fails to treat the concrete cancer, its debt will keep growing
and economic decay could turn into economic collapse and social dislocation.
But if the new prime minister does turn off the cemented tap, then the
consequences could be just as dire. |
Alex
Kerr: |
It's
an addiction in Japan at this point. I mean I think it's heroine. Japan is
well and truly addicted to these public works, and the pain of coming off
that addiction is going to be severe. I truly think the entire society will
collapse and everybody knows that, because at this point, the economy well
and truly depends on the construction. You'd have tends
of millions of people out of work. It would be absolutely devastating. |