Narrator: |
Phnom
Penh, Cambodia, March the 23rd, 1998. It's already early evening by the time
an Australian lawyer-cum-businessman checks into the best hotel in town. By
the next morning, he'd be dead. His face beaten with a bedside table, his
head bashed in with a brick, then he was strangled to death with his own tie. |
|
No
one in the busy hotel says they saw the killers come or go. No one in the
next rooms heard anything. And no one seems to know why he was even here. The
brutal murder remains unsolved. |
|
Fast
forward to the here and now, or at least to neighbouring Laos, and another
unsolved incident involving Australians where fact and fiction remain
confused. Security firm owner Kerry Danes and his wife Kay, arrested on
charges of stealing gems, pilfering from the storerooms of one of the world's
richest deposits of sapphire. |
|
On
the surface, the 1998 murder in Phnom Penh and the arrests in Vientiane
appear unrelated. Yet in one vital way, they remain inextricably linked. For
the shadowy characters who surrounded Melbourne tax lawyer, Max Green, before
his untimely death in Cambodia, are also the main players surrounding the
Danes' jailing over the alleged gem theft in Laos. |
|
Tonight
one of those key characters emerges for the first time to shed new light on
both mysterious events. |
Ted
Doyle: |
And
I was a moral coward and said, "Yeah, don't worry Max, I'll organise
something. I'll get there." And I had no intention of going and ... So
anyway, you can imagine how I feel about Max being used in that way. But as
we get older, we learn to expect nearly anything from human beings. |
Narrator: |
In
the far north of Laos, a mine at Ban Huay Sai, is
one of the world richest deposits of sapphire. After years of plunder, it
could still have $100 million US dollars worth of
stone, a bonanza for the concession holder, a vast source of royalty revenue
for the desperately poor Lao government. |
|
Not
surprisingly, the government keeps a close eye on the dig; some say, too
close an eye. The mine is now shut down and under guard, the subject of a
bitter battle for ownership by two competing foreign groups. But the mine is
really just the final destination on an extraordinary trail of greed, dirty
deals and double crosses, that had its beginnings not in Asia, but in one of
corporate Australia's more respectable precincts, Melbourne's legal quarter. |
Greg
Stokes: |
You're
talking in the period of '93, '94, when the company was called Shugg and Green, solicitors. A small firm with a person
as principle of name of Gary Shugg. |
Narrator: |
Gary
Shugg was a crafty, ambitious lawyer, looking to go
places fast. But to do that in conservative Melbourne, he needed money and
connections. In came Max Green, through marriage plugged into Melbourne's
wealthy establishment. Still, no one could have predicted how quickly their
little firm would grow. |
Greg
Stokes: |
It
was just an expedential growth over a short period
from their letterhead turning from one company based in Melbourne to wanting
to be based in London, New York and Kiev. |
Narrator: |
Greg
Stokes thought it was suspicious because it was his job. Now in private
security, he was then with the Victoria Police and had been called in to
investigate claims that Shugg was stealing other
people's money that he held in trust. But he soon discovered even more
serious allegations that these lawyers were implicated in arms dealing and
money laundering. |
Greg
Stokes: |
Employees
turning around and saying, "Hang on, I've just picked up a fax on our
company fax machine just telling me about howitzers coming from Kiev on the
way to the Cambodian government through Australia. We're a legal company, why
have we got these sorts of faxes coming through?" |
Ted
Doyle: |
You
know, I was brought a letter that said we wanted so many artillery shells
and, what are you doing? Guys, guys, you know, back into the real world, you
know. I mean, you'll either get shot by the Russians, not paid by the
Cambodians, you know, or assassinated by the Chinese bankers, who you then
can't pay, you know, I mean, this is dangerous stuff. |
Narrator: |
Ted
Doyle was a permanent consultant, virtually a third partner to Shugg and Green. A former soldier and intelligence
operative, with heavy connections in Southeast Asia. Police viewed Doyle as
an enforcer, a stand-over man. |
Ted
Doyle: |
I'm
a shadowy figure, you know? It's ridiculous. |
Greg
Stokes: |
Ted's
not someone that you would muck around with. It's someone that has had a
previous military background. It's someone that's been up in Asia for a long period
of time, that had connections in the Asia region, and he could transfer those
connections down to Australia whenever he chose to do. |
|
And
they're the sorts of things that people were scared of. |
Narrator: |
Soon
the Victoria Police had put enough together to bring a series of theft
charges against firm principle, Gary Shugg. But
before they could swoop, Shugg fled the country. As
they continued to look for hard evidence against Green, he went about his
business, travelling to and from Asia, and staying in touch with his old
mate, Ted Doyle, by now settled full time in Southeast Asia. |
Ted
Doyle: |
Look,
I'm just a knock about, I learned a lot. I'm a quick study and I learned a
lot about the gem trade over 20 years of fascination with the things ... And
decided to do it full time. |
Narrator: |
With
his new found knowledge and connections, Ted Doyle became a player in the
Asian gem trade. Here, Doyle and his partner launched their effort to sell
Australian opals to rich Thai buyers, an early opening gambit for their gem
company. But to buy the stones, pay for occasions like this and build a
business, they needed cash and Ted Doyle's business would get it from none
other than Max Green. |
|
Just
as big money had flowed in with Green's arrival at the tiny Melbourne law
firm, so too when he fronted Ted Doyle's gem shop front in Bangkok. |
Speaker
4: |
When
they need you, they just need you in front of them to signature, that's all. |
Narrator: |
Through
her meticulous diaries, one of Ted Doyle's former office workers, recalls how
heavily the business relied on Max Green money. |
Speaker
4: |
Ted
tell me ... Every time we look at the stone [inaudible], and he got no money
with him and he'd say, "We have to wait for Max to send us." Then,
every time we have to wait til money come from Max.
Then it will come like exactly time, like, some time, got no money left and
then everything have to stop, and to wait until next lot come in. |
Narrator: |
Max
Green was sending money here to an account at the swank headquarters of the
Bangkok bank, an account held in the name of Doyle's gem business partner and
it was a lot of money. Bank documents obtained by a foreign correspondent
reveal that between July 1996 and October 1997, Max Green moved almost $20
million dollars from his account held at the branch of the National
Australian Bank in Carlton to Doyle's business in Bangkok. |
|
Doyle
insists it was all aboveboard. Green was sending
the money to buy gems that he later then collect and resell. |
Ted
Doyle: |
If
somebody walked in the door that looked like they just robbed the bank, you
know, smoking gun in their hand and Bangkok bank money bags in their hand,
I'd probably forced to sort of assume that they got it nefariously and call
the police. But if a prominent Jewish lawyer in an Armani suit, with his
brief case walks in the door and says, "Now, look, what I want to do is
transfer, not cash, transfer the funds from my company in Australia to your
account in Bangkok, and then I want to arrive here and pick up certain goods
that I'll specify." Yeah? Problem? Would you have a problem with that,
Evan? |
Narrator: |
But
there was a problem. Max Green's money wasn't his money at all. Victoria's
major fraud squad has now established that Green was lifting the money from
lawyer trust accounts under his control. He was fleecing Melbourne's richest
business people with an elaborate scam; a complicated tax deferral scheme
that didn't even exist. In fact, Max Green wasn't interested in Asian gems at
all. He was simply using them to launder his stolen millions. |
Ted
Doyle: |
I
said, "Maxie, is this kosher?", "Well, what do you mean by,
kosher?". And I immediately thought that he'd meant some weird tax
evasion or tax avoidance scheme, which really didn't impact on us because we
don't live in Australia ,and if he'd done something down there that was
questionable under the tax act and we didn't know about it, well, so what,
right? Silly boy, naughty boy, you go to jail, but not our problem. |
|
But
I had no idea he was stealing it. |
Evan: |
And
did he then tell you that this is actually, I'm laundering the money? |
Ted
Doyle: |
No,
no we just decided ... I mean, I don't need to ask more questions than I need
to ask. I just said, look, that's ... [inaudible] that's it. Wait til Max comes back with a better way of doing this,
whatever it is he's doing. |
Narrator: |
What
it was, was an awesome scam. A staggering 42 million dollars, maybe more. It
seems Green may have been trying to borrow the trust fund money, make profits
on various schemes, and put it back before anyone noticed. |
Ted
Doyle: |
Maxie
sort of envied people who were clever, people who were sort of clients of
his, who skimmed the system and got away with it and scarpered of to his
realm, lived a good life. Leaving the Keystone Cops, jumping up and down on
the spot in Australia, you know. |
Narrator: |
As
Ted Doyle took his commissions and scoured the Southeast Asian landscape for
gem mining opportunities, Max Green took another path, to Cambodia, a place
mentioned in gun running dispatches years back when Green was working with Shugg in Melbourne. With payments due on his bogus tax
scheme and the police getting close, the pressure on Green was growing. He
needed a deal to get him out of the mess he created, and in Cambodia he'd
thought he found it. |
Ted
Doyle: |
What
he was up to, I wouldn't have a clue, Evan. But I'll tell you this, it would
have been mad fantasy and cloud crooked land, like everything else he did
that got him killed, and that's almost the real core of the tragedy. |
Narrator: |
The
tragedy Ted Doyle is referring to is the brutal slaying of Max Green at his
hotel in Cambodia. From police reports and staff interviews we know that
Green dined alone the only night he stayed there. Then he had a visitor.
There were no signs of forced entry, so perhaps he knew the one, possibly two
people who came knocking. |
|
What
is clear is that once inside, they struck quickly and brutally. |
Police
Officer: |
[foreign
language] |
Narrator: |
Taken
from the TV cabinet, this is the only lead the killer left behind. |
Police
Officer: |
[foreign
language] |
Narrator: |
For
the under resourced Cambodian Police, it's not much to go on. Anyway given
Green's bulk, they believe it wasn't a diminutive local, rather a foreigner
leading the attack. |
|
It
wasn't a simple robbery either. Green's gold Cartier watch was left on the
floor and a few thousand dollars left in the safe. But most importantly, what
was taken by the killer was a laptop computer, and discs containing all the
records of his financial transfers, a road map of the stolen millions. |
Evan: |
The
thing smashed the head, like this. |
Narrator: |
But
the investigation stalled; the evidence gathers dust. But they do have one
conclusion. |
Police
Officer: |
[foreign
language] |
Ted
Doyle: |
Max
would never believe people would do you over like that. He'd think he could
talk his way out of anything. Well, there is people here that will kill you
in a blink. |
Greg
Stokes: |
Max
Green was a timid fellow. He'd be the type of person you would put in your
accounting area as your second line or third line. |
Narrator: |
The
same can't be said for Ted Doyle and Green's former Melbourne legal partner
Garry Shugg. |
|
After
his disappearance from Australia, Shugg was about
to re-emerge, join up with Ted Doyle for a financial play that would dwarf
anything that he'd have done before. |
|
After
searching, Ted Doyle had finally found his El Dorado. This huge sapphire mine
in the North of Laos, a place from which he could secure his own supply of
gems. |
|
Much
of the four million dollar profit he made off the trade with Max, Ted Doyle
now sank into this mine, Gem Mining Laos. |
Bernie
Jeppesen: |
He
wakes up [crosstalk] people. |
Narrator: |
It
was owned by this man Ernie Jeppesen and his partner Julie Brunes. They had the concession for 13 years. |
Julie
Brunes: |
[crosstalk] |
Narrator: |
Under
concession rules they paid royalties to the local and national governments,
it was doing all right, but the injection of Doyle's money would help them
increase their production dramatically. |
Bernie
Jeppesen: |
They
brought up Doyle, Ted Doyle. We were actually talking about them selling many
of the sales of all sapphires for us, and we worked out a percentage and they
said, "Oh that's was how it all started." |
Narrator: |
But
Doyle supplied more than just cash, he came with a visionary, Gary Shugg. The man wanted for plundering trust accounts in
Melbourne, had arrived back on the scene and was thinking big. Shugg proposed a public float of the mine, taking it to
the global marketplace through a listing in Canada. |
Bernie
Jeppesen: |
It
all sounded good. We were to haul 53%, they were going to have 47. And it all
looked very promising. |
Evan: |
But
the conflict had already began. |
Narrator: |
But
according to Jeppesen, it was to be no ordinary float. It was to be
accompanied by some non-too-subtle spin, what over ambitious and
non-scrupulous corporate types call "ramping". |
Bernie
Jeppesen: |
And
the first thing when Shugg came along he and Doyle
sat me down in their office and said, "The way we can really make some
big money, like hundreds of millions of dollars, is by ramping this
year's", I knew the terms very well of course, and I said,
"No". |
Evan: |
Just
tell me what that means, for people, "ramping". |
Bernie
Jeppesen: |
Ramping
the shares means, if the shares are worth say really worth four dollars or
so, they ramp them by putting in a big team of workers, write up wrong
reports, sort of like Bre-X, I guess, you know. The
shares go up to 8, 10, 12 dollars or so. They were talking about going to 18
dollars most days. That's what they wanted. |
Evan: |
From
a two dollar value? |
Bernie
Jeppesen: |
Yeah,
basically. |
Narrator: |
The
Doyle-Shugg camp reject the ramping claims as
rubbish. In any event, the big public listing of the sapphire mine,
registered and ready to go, half a world away in Vancouver, Canada, was sunk,
even before it floated. The deal fell apart when Jeppesen and Brunes feared they were about to be short-changed in the
allocation of shares. |
Julie
Brunes: |
When
our lawyer checked into it, the shares were not in our name. Shugg still had his hand in it. |
Ted
Doyle: |
They
went in willingly and wholeheartedly until that public company arrangement. I
think frankly, that they decided that they could take the investor's money,
milk the public company for all that it was worth, and end up still owning
the mine. |
Narrator: |
As
the bitter tug-of-war over the mine through up claim and counter-claim,
officials begin to take closer look at the dig. |
Speaker
10: |
Did
you see the family [inaudible]. |
Speaker
11: |
No. |
Kay
Danes: |
I
love my children. |
Narrator: |
The
probe revealed a swag of missing gems and with concessionaries Jeppesen and Brunes out of the country, the police moved on the man
guarding the treasure, former SAS soldier turned security officer, Kerry
Danes. He and his wife Kay were arrested and accused of stealing gems. |
Evan: |
Obviously
you hope this will help the Danes. |
Bernie
Jeppesen: |
We
certainly hope they'll let them go once this... |
Narrator: |
In
a bid to prove the Danes of stolen nothing, Julie and Bernie for the first
time show that they in fact have at least some of the jewels that that Lao
government accuses Kerry Danes of stealing. They had the New Zealand embassy
sign a statutory declaration witnessing their possession of finished jewels,
they say are rightfully theirs, with all duties already paid to the Lao
government. |
Bernie
Jeppesen: |
Well
this is in order to prove to the Lao government the jewellery is in our
possession down here, in Julie's possession, it's not taken by Kerry or Kay
Danes, and they have nothing at all to do with it. |
Narrator: |
Even
the enemy concedes the Danes are probably innocent. |
Ted
Doyle: |
But
for the Danes it would have been rich cake. Wow these guys have got this
country wide and I'm starting to start a business and I can really go places
with this, you know? So I don't think the Danes sort of actually pinched
anything. |
Narrator: |
None
of this is likely to sway the authorities in Laos, where an absentee trial
has already been played out. Without putting their case, Ernie Jeppesen and
Julie Brunes have been found guilty on unspecified
charges regarding the removal of gems and falsifying documents and have been
sentenced to twenty years in jail and more than 55 million dollars in fines. |
|
And
yet, despite the outcome of the court case, the Danes are still in custody,
simply for their association with the mining company. |
|
For
the man who first investigated the antics of Shugg,
Green and Doyle back in Melbourne in the early '90s there are no surprises
that the trio resurfaced in the relatively unregulated backwaters of
southeast Asia. Along with their dubious deals, all ending up over their
head, one paying the ultimate price. |
Greg
Stokes: |
I
would hope that it would be solved, not as though you didn't have a body, you
didn't have a scene, and you didn't have the police actually looking at it.
But it seems to be that Max Green's death is continuing to be a link to a
sapphire mine where previous associates now are involved with it. |
Evan: |
So
this is the actual company is it? |
Narrator: |
So
what of close associate Ted Doyle? His business was a syphon for more than 20
million dollars of Max Green's stolen money. But he laughs off claims that
something went very wrong and business got bloody. Murder, that he says, is
beyond him. |
Ted
Doyle: |
[crosstalk]
if we can follow that mine up there, we'll do it again. |
Evan: |
People
will often report that you had him killed because then you wouldn't have to
pay the money back. |
Ted
Doyle: |
Yeah,
right. My standard response to that sort of allegation is "I always kill
people who are giving me money, it's a standard operating procedure of mine,
and that's why I'm broke." I'm not going to rise to that, that's silly. |
Evan: |
That
absolves you, that's where it keeps getting lift, that's why we keep looking
for something else that might have been there, did he ever get [crosstalk]- |
Ted
Doyle: |
Let's
me put this to you. There's a great list of people who have mixed histories
that Max took money off, stole money off. Now, why wouldn't one of them be
asking for his money back? I mean, you know, lets, lets- |
Evan: |
These
are the people [inaudible] |
Ted
Doyle: |
Yeah,
let's use our brains a bit. |
Narrator: |
Whatever
the motive of his assailant, it was really greed that killed Max Green. Today
it's again greed that's led to the double deals over control of a gem mine
that's left two Australians in a Lao jail. But it should not be forgotten,
that much of the money that greased the wheels of both events, slipped
through leading institutions in Australia, whose checks and balances either
failed or never existed. |