KARACHI
A City At War With Itself
script - November 1995
15 minutes
01.00.09 |
Putting body into car |
v/o He's Mother Theresa of Pakistan... To many he's almost a saint... Everyday Sattar Edhi collects the dead and abandoned from the streets of Karachi. |
00.22 |
Edhi's ambulance/car Edhi driving |
SOT ambulance siren and driving sounds Around him, one of the world's biggest cities is descending into chaos. |
00.51 |
Shovelling dirt Getting body out of car Edhi organising men to pray Burial sequence |
NATSOT digging Praying Edhi: 'allahu akbah'
A one man social security system, Sattar
Edhi and his volunteers run clinics and emergency centres, take in unwanted babies and bury unwanted dead. |
01.21 |
Long shots of the cemetery showing grave markers |
Edhi's massive graveyard outside Karachi looks like a war cemetery. Most buried here don't have names, only numbers. |
01.31 |
- traffic wipe to reveal Edhi in ambulance, he pulls up, gets out of car and walks into office (tho not out of shot) |
NATSOT traffic, probably siren This year alone more than fourteen hundred people have been killed in Karachi. Its become one of the most dangerous places
on earth. In the middle of the city, Edhi headquarters are an island in the storm. |
02.06 |
Edhi intvu |
SYNC Edhi SUB TITLE - Our country's political situation is being run by feudal landlords, tribal leaders, tax cheating industrialists. They’ve all grouped together to totally take over and run the country. |
02.23 |
- speeding ambulance thru virtually empty streets - also shot of siren and flashing light on top of ambulance |
NATSOT ambulance siren, horn blowing Today, as it does about once a week, the city is grinding to a standstill. The MQM, the party with de facto control of Karachi, is showing its strength by calling
a strike day. |
02.45 |
- sequence of racing ambulance, tracking shots of closed shops radio - tast tracking shot past closed shops and narrow lanes radio sot |
SOT - SUB-TITLE: There's a lot of security . ...also a lot of burnt cars. Each cross road is a snipers alley...... in
this part of town any driver is a strike breaker, any car or bus is a target. SOT - SUB-TITLE: They have a lot of weapons and there are small lanes...we can't get in there. |
|
- driving past and then stopping in front of line of police/ paramilitary vans |
There's no official war here but much of Karachi looks like a battlefield. Two years ago the MQM, an ethnically Indian party won Karachi's elections. Pakistans government threw them out and brought in the army. After months of battles and bloodshed the army withdrew. Now Karachi has thirty thousand police and paramilitaries. |
03.36 |
03.36 - Drive up to body, get out of car look at body. body being rolled over, loaded on to stretcher and put into ambulance police collecting 'evidence' at scene |
The one constant has been Karachi's growing death toll. Behind some houses, this empty land is a regular dumping ground for bodies. The feet and hands are bound, there are signs of torture. Most likely it's an MQM assassination, the fate of an informer. Its barely matters. In a city fueled by
drug dealing, gun running, and bribery ...murder is expected. |
04.27 |
Edhi sync could overlay first sentence and cut line from to |
SYNC Edhi SUB TITLE - In every neighbourhood there's a centre where the criminals operate and control the They sell alcohol at ordinary people night, gamble, blackmail the neighbours extort money. And during elections and demonstrations, they're used by the political parties. |
04.51 |
interior shot of police station looking out thru bars |
NATSOT A few blocks from the dumping ground the local police station is stranded on a frontline. |
05.00 |
- paramilitary post on roof....if time, empty streets as well |
Behind it, paramilitaries man the rooftops, in front of it, MQM snipers hide in the streets. |
|
- kids running to see body, crowd gathers round, untying feet and wrists policeman writing on clipboard - cutaways of kids and adults looking |
For the police, a dead body is routine paperwork. Investigating is almost out of the question. Identifying the victim is hard enough, finding the criminal...is almost impossible. Its a black joke in Karachi that when the
police hear gunfire, they run in the opposite direction. |
05.32 |
- int of police station - police on phone, putting paperwork in cupboard, maybe the ext of the cells Identikit pix on wall talking beside identikit computer operator |
But it's hardly surprising. They're paid a pittance and almost every day one of them is murdered. It's a sign of the decay that Karachi's only computerised investigation system has been developed by a millionaire businessman. SYNC Yusuf (english) - And we develop it a bit further till we have a proper sketch of the person. And do the police have anything like this? |
06.08 |
sequence of identikit on screen with facial elements changing, plus - other stuff roound the room of computers |
A. No the police do not. I mean this is the only computer available not only in Karachi, but in Pakistan." (19 sex) Jamil Yusuf's unlikely career change began when a spree of kidnappings blitzed Karachi's businessmen. Helped out by the army, Yusuf tapped phones,
and did what the police hadnt...... in his
words, he wiped out the kidnappers. Since then, Jamil Yusuf has been taking on a new and more difficult target. |
06.36 |
Jamil Yusuf intvu |
SYNC: SYNC english - In Karachi you can say theres been a total
collapse of the rule of law which has been decaying for quite a few years |
06.46 |
2 shot etc |
Corrupt police, argues Yusuf, are the willing tools of corrupt politicians. In Karachi, he says, theres
a fine line between police fighting criminals and the government targetting its opposition. |
07.03 |
Jamil Yusuf intvu |
SYNC english Theres been extortion going on, people are suffering, theyd be willing to swap over to
the government provided they feel confidence in the government, provided innocent people are not
put behind bars and implicated in wrong cases. |
07.19 |
camels, women on beach |
NATSOT and music How much people really support the MQM is arguable. When it was in power it did little to help them. Now that its out, its battle with the
government is killing Pakistans richest commercial
centre. |
07.46 |
port, ships, containers |
Karachi's still the country's biggest port but foreign investors are fleeing. Local businesses are crippled by strikes and shutdowns. These days, living in Karachi and avoiding the city's battle is getting more and more difficult.....
|
08.03 |
- glittery lights, balloons people chatting at party Sameer in dark suit, shirt and tie |
SOT general party noises but some are still trying. A night out for Karachi's well to do often means an expensive party at a five star hotel. Though he probably doesnt realise it,
tonight, Samir is the guest of honour. |
08.32 |
- mum and sameer holding big sharp knife - balloons burst etc - if this cuts - if not leave out SOT and continue v/o |
SOT - can we get 'happy birthday' singing around the cake in here? He's celebrating his first birthday. |
|
- musical chairs sequence , enthusiastic parents encouraging their kids |
SOT musical chairs music and kids/ parents screeching Like his friends the chances are Samir will grow up in a divided city, he'll drive to work on flyovers that that by pass the poor suburbs, live behind shuttered windows.... and keep security guards outside his door. (backlay first cpla
words of PTC and mix with more Happy Birthday music) This is the other side of Karachi, the old home town of Pakistans PM Benazir Bhutto.
But these days she spends little time here. Karachi's influential rfamilies may still be here
making money, but on the other side of their security fences, pakistans biggest city is running
out of control...and they like the PM are doing little to stop it. |
09.18 |
|
SYNC Bhutto (english) As a K'ite I've been very concernd about the rise of the politics of violence and the rise of politics of violence has been associated with an ethnic party known as the MQM 1944 Q. Do you accept though that the MQM does
have public support in Karachi? 1949 1 dont think MQM has monopoly on
Karachi, no. MQM has pockets of support where it has been assisting in the illegal immigration trade and where people live in slums and blahs and there's a sense of deprivation so they have been trying to exploit that sense of deprivation.(edit) It started off in 1985 an d it exhorted
people to in videos and tv and to buy arms and theres
been a killing spree. |
10.07 |
Hospital Emergency ext, cops with guns? Edhi ambulance arriving |
NATSOT brief But Karachis' terror is only one danger. Years of neglect have added others, almost as lethal. |
|
getting her out of ambulance Faisal (in glasses) lifting foot of stretcher doctors fumbling with power point, blood everywhere blood drip, etc to complete sequence |
A mother of ten, Sardara Begum did nothing more than ride in a bus on an MQM strike day. Now Sattar Edhis son Faisal has rushed her
to hospital in an voluntary ambulance. Faisal (english) What happened On a bus..she's
been shot twice cut to reverse qu...what sort of condition
is she in ? Pretty grim Sadaras been brought to Civil Hospital -
one of only four government emergency hospitals in a city of eight million people. This is casualty. The chances of saving a life here are minimal. The blood drip, if it works has to be
carried. Theres little light, little equipment and
little thats clean. Even Baghdads hospitals after years of
sanctions, are in better condition. |
11.14 |
- manual weaving on loom continue weaving |
NATSOT clunking of manual loom Turning Karachi around now could be demanding the impossible. Even the small traditional industries are dying. In Karachi's poor northern suburbs, weavers are known for their fine silk and delicate patterns. A full day's weaving only earns four dollars... but now even that's getting difficult. |
11.44 |
women, plus another translating - Overlay beginning of last grab of woman various shots women |
two [backlay over clunking loom or cont clunking loom to cover women] SYNC SUB TITLE You know you never know when a bullet might come in and hit you - it could be anytime from anywhere. Between them Saira and Alia have ten
children. They weave at home, often surrounded by fighting. But selling their silk has become almost impossible, its difficult to travel and the
nearby shop is too afraid to open. |
12.09 |
Berween walking and talking thru poor
streets some side streets |
SOT street sounds In some areas and for some years, Karachi ites
have been picking up the pieces. Abandoned by governments the people of Orangi
built a self-help project that's been copied all over the world. |
|
|
It was they say all working reasonably well tili
a few months ago, when the government brought in the paramilitary. Since then there's been more violence and shooting. It's a sign of the crisis that Pakistan's government has begun talking to the MOM opposition. |
12.38 |
Question Woman answers. |
What do people think about talks, do they take them seriously? No not at all. So far the talks have gone nowhere. |
12.48 |
SYNC Bhutto interview Question Bhutto Question Bhutto Question Bhutto |
How much can a government fo . That's what I'd like to ask because we have fed people this false notion that the government can take care of everything from the cradle to the grave. Of course a government can't do everything,
I appreciate that point but can you understand how people would fee/ angry with the governemnt
and alienated from it when they have to live in
the miserable sons of conditions that there are in amny
parts of Karachi? yes peo/e were angry but who was
responsible, it was the MQM They were in government in '87, they were in governement in '88, they were in government in 1990... what did they do for the people of Karachi? They ate up the money of Karachi, they used it to pay their cadres, they used it on entertainment, they used it in guns, they used it to transfer money to foreign countries. And can the press write about it - no Karachi's press can't write because if Karachi's press write about it -
they get killed. I'm sorry Can we go onto other questions ? May I just ask one more question ? No because I've answered enough questions on this |
13.57 |
Jamil Yusuf |
SYNC Yusuf (english) Now its nearly all over the city. Its not that I can close my eyes to another part because it has reached my house also. The fire has spread and I may be a victim tomorrow. I might be living in any other district of Karachi but I could be a victim very fast. |
14.15 |
kids in orphanage playground, on swings, playing with Mr and Mrs |
NATSOT kids playing noises Karachi does still have its optimists and ideallists.
Ask Sattar Edhi where he finds hope....and he'll bring you here to one of his orphanages. Karachis orphans call Sattar Edhi and his
wife mummy and daddy .... They too are Karachi's victims - the children of the poor and the murdered. |
14.53 |
|
I've buried 135,000 people, taken care of 260,000 destitutes but none of it means as
much to me as spending time with these children. |
|
Kubra sync |
To these children, Sattar Edhi means hope. Their city may need a lot but what theyre
asking for is heart breakingly little. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|