USA - President Hillary?
16' 16"
©2008
ABC Ultimo Centre
700 Harris Street Ultimo
NSW 2007 Australia
GPO Box 9994
Sydney
NSW 2001 Australia
Phone: 61 2 8333 4383
Fax: 61 2 8333 4859
Publicity: | Can Hillary Rodham Clinton become the second member of her family to become President of the United States of America? |
|
| Is she on an ego trip to match the achievement of husband, bad boy Bill, or does she really have the vision to be a much more successful President Clinton? |
|
| A few months ago Clinton's nomination seemed inevitable - but she's facing a very real challenge from the charismatic Barack Obama, who's promising a break from the past and hope for the future. |
|
| Washington Correspondent Tracy Bowden has been tracking the Hillary bandwagon through the slush and snow of the Democratic primary elections. |
|
| Clinton has tackled head-on one of the biggest issues telling the faithful in New Hampshire, "I am proud to be running to be the first woman president. It is historic, it is exciting, but I am not running because I am a woman, I am running because I believe I have the qualifications and the experience to do the job that needs to be done starting January 2009." |
|
| Clinton has made many enemies in her political career but few more poisonous than former Bill Clinton advisor Dick Morris. He tells Bowden that if Americans knew the real Hillary they'd never vote for her. "They would find her cold and aloof and calculating as a person, and they would find her hopelessly to the left as a politician and the American people would reject that." |
|
| Another hurdle is that Americans have become disillusioned through the Bush Administration with dynastic politics. Bush the younger has alienated many who admired the first President George Bush, and many worry about the influence Bill Clinton would have over Hillary. |
|
| Sally Bedell Smith, who wrote For Love of Politics: Bill and Hillary Clinton: The White House Years tells Bowden, "By virtue of his quite outsized dominating domineering personality he (Bill) could be a real intimidating force in the White House. So there are some inherent dangers in it because there will be two presidents; it could even distort the way the executive branch is supposed to function." |
|
| Bedell Smith, Morris and other American political insiders who know the Clintons provide unique insights and reveal what sort of president Hillary Clinton would be. |
|
Hillary at rally | HILLARY: Would we ever elect a woman president? And I don't think we'll know ‘til we try and I'm going to try and with your help I think we can do it. (cheers) | 00:00 |
| BOWDEN: From the moment Hillary Clinton announced her candidacy, her character and qualifications have been challenged. | 00:25 |
Dick Morris | DICK MORRIS: The real Hillary is cold and calculating, the real Hillary is a policy wonk. | 00:33 |
Anne Wexler | ANNE WEXLER: I don't think she is cold and calculating at all, I think she is smart and organised. | 00:38 |
Hillary at support rally | Intro: The next president of the United States, Senator Hillary Clinton... HAROLD ICKES: Most people in America know Hillary Clinton from the bashing that | 00:43 |
Harold Ickes Clinton Adviser | the Republicans inflicted on her eight years in the White House, that is their total understanding of her. | 00:51 |
Sally Bedell Smith Author For Love of Politics | SALLY BEDELL SMITH: She sometimes isn't as unflappable as she would like everybody to believe. There's a certain emotional vulnerability that she has that hasn't shown. | 00:57 |
Hillary meets and greets | DICK MORRIS: The single biggest challenge that Hillary has, is that if people knew what she was really like as a person and what she really believes in as a politician they would never vote for her. | 01:10 |
Morris. Super: Dick Morris Former Clinton advisor | They would find her cold and aloof and calculating and all that as a person, and they would find her hopelessly to the left as a politician and the American people would reject that. | 01:19 |
News story 1996 | Commentary: It could hardly have happened at a worse time, on the eve of Bill Clinton's acceptance speech a sex scandal involving his most senior political advisor, Dick Morris. BOWDEN: He was once Bill Clinton's most trusted advisor... | 01:31 |
Dick Morris file footage | DICK MORRIS: I was sitting with the President one night and we were working on some speech... BOWDEN: ...but in 1996 Dick Morris was forced to resign, after it was revealed he had allowed a prostitute to listen in on conversations with the President. He's now re-invented himself | 01:45 |
Dick Morris | as a Hillary Clinton critic. DICK MORRIS: I believe Hillary would be a very liberal president and I think she would take the United States in directions that would be very harmful to us. | 02:01 |
| BOWDEN: You went from being part of the Clinton's inner circle, to I guess being on the outer, | 02:09 |
| has that jaundiced your views? DICK MORRIS: Well, my views on Bill Clinton have never changed, I think he was a very good president and I still feel that, particularly from the neck up. (laughs) | 02:15 |
Hillary file footage/photos | The very qualities that made Hillary a joy to work for as a campaign manager make her a little bit scary as a president. That sort of steel trap mind, the dogmatic approach to stuff, the feeling that the ends justify the means, | 02:27 |
Morris | the willingness to be as aggressive as necessary in winning an election. | 02:41 |
Hillary at New Hampshire rally
| HILLARY: I want to be a president who sets goals and here are my four big goals; number one I want to restore America's leadership around the world; Number 2, I want to rebuild a strong and prosperous middle class, Number 3, I want to reform the government so it works competently again, and number four I want to reclaim the future for our children. | 02:46 |
| HAROLD ICKES: Hillary Clinton is a progressive in the true sense of that word. You know she -- I would not characterise | 03:08 |
Ickes. Super: | her as left, but I would characterise her as a real progressive who understands that government is not the end all and the be all, on the other hand she understands that government can serve very important functions. | 03:14 |
| BOWDEN: Harold Ickes is still in the Clinton inner circle. The veteran strategist helped Hillary Clinton run for the senate in 2000, and is back on board for this campaign. | 03:26 |
| HAROLD ICKES: There are some very big, profound issues. Economic security is clearly one and one of the key issues within that big issue is health care. I think re-orienting the economy. Again, not big, huge changes, but refocusing the economy so that we are not burdened by huge deficits and tackling Iraq and our image around the world, those are, those are , that's a big order for the first four years. | 03:37 |
| Music | 04:06 |
Iraq | BOWDEN: With Americans increasingly worried about being tipped into a recession, the economy has become the top issue in this election, but there is still enormous concern amongst voters about the war in Iraq. HILLARY in debate: I have said repeatedly | 04:08 |
MSNBC debate | that I will begin to bring our troops home as soon as I am president, because it is abundantly clear that President Bush does not intend to end the war while he is still president. | 04:24 |
Iraq | BOWDEN: Hillary Clinton voted for the war back in 2002 - Barack Obama says he's opposed it from the start. | 04:36 |
MSNBC debate | OBAMA in debate: But the real key for the next president is someone who has the credibility of not having been one of the co-authors of this engagement in Iraq. And I think I'm in a strong position to be able to say I thought this was a bad idea in the first place, we now have to fix it, we have to be as careful getting out as we were careless getting in. | 04:45 |
Stop Her Now - animator | Music | 05:05 |
| BOWDEN: A war of a different kind is being waged by the anti-Hillary forces - the Hillary haters. | 05:10 |
| ANIMATOR: The objective of this is to show Hillary in all of her different attitudes. | 05:17 |
The Hillary Show | Hillary Show on website: It's the Hillary Show with special guest former president and active ladies man, wild Bill Clinton. | 05:25 |
| BOWDEN: StopHerNow is a website aimed at doing just that, with a selection of anti-Hillary news, blogs and cartoons. | 05:34 |
Hillary Show on website | BILL animation: I've given motivational speeches all over the world. HILLARY animation: Let's not mention the $125 thousand we received for each of those. | 05:42 |
Collins in meeting | MAN: ‘Tonight's guest is my 2 timing but necessary husband - my man Bill. | 05:52 |
| BOWDEN: Texan millionaire Richard Collins is the founder of StopHerNow. COLLINS: Does he say anything? | 05:57 |
| BOWDEN: He believes Hillary Clinton as President would be a disaster for America. BOWDEN: Why go to all this trouble? COLLINS: Well I've been active in political affairs most of my life, | 06:05 |
Collins. Super: | and I think that my contribution for this particular election cycle was to try to define the real Hillary Clinton, She is trying to make herself really a centrist candidate, when she represents the ultimate liberal wing of American politics, which is more government, more taxes and worse times for everybody in my opinion. | 06:13 |
The Hillary Show on website | HILLARY animation: He has no experience, no record and no chance. He's my very, very, very good friend Obama Orama or whatever. BOWDEN: How much money you are spending on this ? COLLINS: We have spent about | 06:37 |
Collins | 400 thousand dollars so far and I expect that by the time the cycle is completed we will probably have spent three or four million. | 06:50 |
Hillary - New Hampshire | HILLARY: I am not running because I am a woman, I am running because I believe that I have the qualifications and experience to do the job that needs to be done starting in January 2009. (applause) | 06:58 |
| BOWDEN: The issue of experience has been a double-edged sword in the Clinton campaign. | 07:10 |
| At first, it was her main selling point. But just what experience? And how relevant is it to running the world's most powerful nation? Bowden: What about experience - that's obviously | 07:19 |
Morris. Super: Dick Morris | one of the things that she's pushing - that she has experience. DICK MORRIS: There is nothing more bankrupt than Hillary's expression of experience; I was in the White House, you know, the pastry chef was there too, he can't run for president saying he was experienced. | 07:31 |
Wexler. Super: Anne Wexler | ANNE WEXLER: In addition to her years in the White House, as I said, she has had eight years in the senate which is a heck of a lot more than Barack Obama has had and he's running for president. | 07:42 |
Anne working/photo Anne and Bill | BOWDEN: Lobbyist and former aide to presidents Carter and Clinton, Anne Wexler, gave Hillary Rodham a job in the early 1970s at the request of another young employee, Bill Clinton. They are firm friends. ANNE WEXLER: She has had an enormous amount of experience, | 07:52 |
File footage. Young Bill and Hillary | not only in the work she did as the first lady of Arkansas, as a lawyer, as the president of the Children's Defence Fund, she has been an advocate for children's issues for 25 years. She served on the armed services committee as a senator and she has had a lot of foreign policy exposure, | 08:08 |
Wexler | so I think she has had a lot of experience, in many ways more than a lot of the other candidates. | 08:29 |
| BOWDEN: Do you think that when she was in the White House she had a lot to do with policy? | 08:33 |
| ANNE WEXLER: Just on some policy, not on all policy, but you know, I think the conversations between presidents and first ladies, especially with this president and this first lady, both of whom are really smart, is pretty sophisticated. SALLY BEDELL SMITH: Her main role, was that of a behind the scenes | 08:37 |
Bedell Smith. Super: Sally Bedell Smith | consultant, the hidden hand, and in that capacity she did have a role in talking to her husband advising her husband - sometimes even insisting on things. | 08:56 |
Sally set-up shot/ Book shots | BOWDEN: Sally Bedell Smith interviewed dozens of Washington insiders for her book on the Clintons. SALLY BEDELL SMITH: She knows the mechanics of the White House, how things function, where everything is, but in terms | 09:10 |
Bedell Smith | of actual executive experience or leadership experience obviously the only area in which she had a chance to show that was in her | 09:23 |
File Hillary | leading the health care reform effort, which did not end well and didn't show great leadership skills. HILLARY: Nothing is more important to our nation | 09:34 |
| than ensuring that every American has comprehensive health care benefits that can never be taken away. ANNE WEXLER: Neither the insurance industry or the pharmaceutical industry had any interest whatsoever in supporting it, but I think the atmosphere is different today, I think by and large, | 09:45 |
Wexler | a large majority of the American public are ready for health care -- some kind of universal health care. | 10:02 |
Tracking shots snowy Iowa | Music | 10:09 |
| BOWDEN: We followed Hillary Clinton as she travelled across the snowy farmlands of Iowa and on to New Hampshire, campaigning in school gyms and town halls. | 10:15 |
Hillary meeting and greeting | These are tightly controlled affairs, with few opportunities for the pesky media to get up close and personal. | 10:28 |
| A vigilant security detail is ever-present; standard procedure for a former first lady. | 10:36 |
Hillary coughing | Such a gruelling schedule, with back to back events, day after day, is bound to take its toll. HILLARY: I've been fighting this for a while...[coughing] | 10:44 |
T1 New Hampshire | MAN in crowd: Hang in there! HILLARY: I will, that's one thing you know about me, I hang in there! (laughter/cheers) | 11:00 |
Terry McAuliffe. Clinton campaign | TERRY MCAULIFFE: Ladies and gentleman, the former president of the United States of America and the next president of the United States of America, Bill and Hillary Clinton! | 11:12 |
| BOWDEN: Hillary Clinton has been joined on the campaign trail by her famous husband. | 11:24 |
‘Capitol Steps'. Shakespearean Bill and Hillary | Grab ‘Bill: Romeo, Romeo, wherefore I am a Romeo. | 11:31 |
| BOWDEN: The Clinton dramas have provided endless material for Washington's satirists. | 11:36 |
| Grab ‘Hillary': M'Lord, I considereth running for the highest office in all of the land, but alas I fear my past doth haunt me like an ill wind was blown... | 11:40 |
White House | BOWDEN: But just what role would Bill Clinton play if his wife does become president? | 11:51 |
Morris | DICK MORRIS: Bill wants Hillary to get elected for one big reason; it will wipe out the stain of impeachment. | 11:56 |
‘Capitol Steps' | Grab ‘Bill': But for this one small indiscretion I hath paid, if only I had said ‘out damn spot.' DICK MORRIS: He will no longer be the second president to be | 12:01 |
Morris. Super: Dick Morris | impeached, but the first president in effect to have his wife elected for a third term for him. But it is not really going to be a third term for him, | 12:13 |
Bill Clinton with dog | he will go around the globe, and be an ambassador and preside at charities, and I think he will be queen, not king. (laughs) | 12:20 |
Bill and Hillary wave | BOWDEN: But the idea of a re-run of the ‘buy one, get one free' deal raises serious concerns for Sally Bedell Smith. SALLY BEDELL-SMITH: We would be facing, not just a President Hillary Clinton and a first spouse, but we would have two presidents, but also by virtue of his quite outsize domineering dominating personality he could be a real | 12:29 |
Bedell Smith. Super: Sally Bedell Smith | intimidating force in the White House, so there are some inherent dangers in it. | 12:52 |
Bill Clinton with Bush | ANNE WEXLER: I think the biggest problem is the dynasty issue, | 13:00 |
Wexler | and I think that will come up again and again, too many years of Bushes and Clintons. | 13:06 |
Debate | OBAMA: Wait Hillary - you just spoke - HILLARY: I did not... OBAMA: ...you just spoke for 2 minutes. HILLARY: I did not say anything about Ronald Regan. You said two things. You talked about admiring... OBAMA: You spoke... BOWDEN: The democratic alternative to that scenario is Barack Obama. During January, the duel between the cashed-up front-runners, became increasingly intense, and personal. | 13:11 |
January 21 Debate | OBAMA: ...because while I was working on those streets watching those folks see their jobs shift overseas, you were a corporate lawyer sitting on the board at WalMart. I was fighting these fights. | 13:29 |
| HILLARY: And I was fighting against those ideas when you were practising law and representing your contributor Rezko in his slum landlord business in inner city Chicago. | 13:38 |
| BOWDEN: Barack Obama promises the fresh approach Americans are yearning for; a country united to battle trouble at home and abroad. | 13:54 |
Obama | OBAMA: It was our message when we were down and it was our message when we were up and it must be catching on because in these last few weeks everyone is talking about change. | 14:03 |
Obama meet and greet | BOWDEN: With Barack Obama now a serious contender for the democratic nomination, voters saw an unexpected display from Hillary Clinton. | 14:14 |
Hillary at microphone | HILLARY: This is very personal for me, it is not just political, it is not just public, I see what is happening, we have to reverse it. And some people think elections are a game, they think it's like who's up or who's down. It is about our country. | 14:27 |
| HAROLD ICKES: It is a challenge to be the first woman president. I mean the question is can, is she able to do it, | 14:45 |
Ickes | is she competent, does she have the fortitude to do it, just generally can a woman do this. I think the debates - in the past 9 or so debates have really shown that Hillary can be Commander in Chief. I think there is nobody now who has watched her perform in the debates who have questions about whether she could be Commander in Chief. | 14:51 |
Hillary meet and greet | ANNE WEXLER: To have the first woman president of the United States is a huge thing to begin with, but I think it will make a difference in the world. | 15:15 |
Wexler. Super: Anne Wexler | I think instantly our credibility will change, simply by virtue of not only having a woman president, but also the fact that she has an international reputation and a very good record and I think it will be easy for her to reach out to other leaders around the world. | 15:24 |
Clinton/Obama shots | Music | 15:43 |
| BOWDEN: So will the baby-boomer, former first lady triumph over the charismatic voice of a new generation? While it won't be official until the convention in August, Democrats could well be pinning their hopes for a return to the White House on a Clinton who would follow a Bush who followed a Clinton who followed a Bush. | 15:48 |
| Music | 16:09 |
| Reporter: Tracy Bowden Camera: Dan Sweetapple, Tim Bates Editor: Woody Landay | 16:16
|