Publicity:
One respected authority who’s seen it first-hand doesn’t mince his words. The rate and scale of forest clearing in Sumatra by big paper producers approaches ecological Armageddon.
“I thought I’d seen, you know, impressive deforestation in the Amazon and parts of Africa. But what’s happening there (Sumatra) on a large industrial scale is pretty daunting …some of the worst forest destruction I’ve ever seen anywhere.” BILL LAURANCE Forest Scientist
Riau province in Sumatra is home to the world’s biggest paper plant. It’s owned and run by Asia Pacific Resources International Ltd, better known by the more disarming acronym APRIL. The company has embarked on a massive land clearing project, removing natural stands of timber and replanting fast-growing acacia trees and when it’s done it says the plantation timber alone will feed the plant. APRIL describes this program as sustainable and certainly preferable to the ad hoc land clearing and burning which blights so much of the Indonesia archipelago.
“We’re doing it in a responsible way in line with what the Indonesian government wants to promote as part of developing forestry and if we don’t do it the way we’re doing it, it can be even worse.” DAVID KERR Director of Operations, APRIL
As the carbon debate rages, Indonesia correspondent Matt Brown ventures into the rapidly diminishing Sumatran jungle, destruction adding dramatically to Indonesia’s greenhouse gas outputs and catapulting the nation high up the list of the world’s worst emitters.
Foreign Correspondent focuses on the activities of APRIL in Riau province where its gargantuan development has led to a bustling town of 250,000 people, many working for and benefiting from APRIL’s plantation and factory. It produces office paper sold by some of Australia’s largest retailers.
But our team explores beyond what APRIL proffers as a model development, to investigate claims of corruption in a nearby area where logging companies appear to have bribed their way into operation. An APRIL subsidiary has been implicated in a paper trail leading to a powerful local political figure now in jail for accepting bribes in return for production permits.
And we investigate the implications of major plantation and milling development on Sumatra’s sensitive and carbon-loaded peat beds. As the bulldozers move through the peat beds, peat dries in the sun and enormous clouds of greenhouse gas are expelled into the atmosphere.
Environmentalists and many villagers worry about the dramatic changes reshaping the land and also about the plight of residents who’ve been there a lot longer than most - like the Sumatran tiger.
“It breaks my heart because they have a right to live here and they’re even here before us, but people just keep taking so much from them. I feel really sorry for the tigers because there will be more forests destroyed.” KARMILA PARAKKASI WWF
Further Information:
As part of our investigation we sought input from two major companies who sell and distribute APRIL paper in Australia. The program asked Officeworks and Fuji Xerox to answer a number of questions. Officeworks hasn’t responded, but here’s what
Fuji Xerox
had to say.
Misty hills of Riau Province
Music
00:00
Gibbons in trees
BROWN: High in the hills of Riau Province, the haunting call of the native gibbon heralds each new day.
00:14
The forest canopy conceals some of the world’s rarest wildlife, including the endangered Sumatran tiger.
00:26
Music
00:34
Karmila and team in forest
00:37
BROWN: Karmila Parakkasi and her team from the World Wildlife Fund track tigers searching for paw prints on the forest floor.
00:44
Tiger prints
The magnificent predators have long been regarded with awe.
00:55
Team member takes photo of print
Music
00:59
Karmila and team in forest
KARMILA PARAKKASI: [Tiger researcher, WWF] “Local people believe that tigers are their elders, the most respected ones.”
01:02
Karmila. Super:
Karmila Parakkasi
Tiger researcher, WWF
It’s kind of like their guard, you know, to say that, ‘Hey you’re doing something bad, so I’m coming down here, I warn you’.
01:10
Tiger camera. WWF vision
Music
01:19
BROWN: The team places cameras in strategic parts of the forest and sets them to automatically film passing tigers. When they get lucky, it’s a sight to behold.
01:23
KARMILA PARAKKASI: “It’s a thrill for us. It’s just an amazing feeling to see these cubs, healthy cubs, playing”.
01:36
BROWN: The Sumatran tiger has roamed here, isolated from the rest of the world, for at least six thousand years. But their territory is under relentless assault, and now less than four hundred tigers survive.
01:46
Aerial. Plantations.
Around sixty per cent of Riau’s forests have already been cleared to make way for vast palm oil and pulp and paper plantations.
02:03
Night vision. Tiger camera/Bulldozers
The tiger team’s videos say it all – a male tiger sniffs the camera, a week later bulldozers move in. The next day, another tiger wanders through the flattened land.
02:15
Karmila
KARMILA PARAKKASI: “I feel really sorry for the tigers, because definitely it’s a really bad sign for their future.
02:33
Wildlife officials in forest
There will be more forest destroyed”.
BROWN: As the forest is cleared and replaced with plantations, the tigers are running out of room,
02:43
Super: Greenpeace video
and without the natural protection of the jungle, they can more easily fall foul of poachers. Just last month this tiger was found in a plantation snared by a trap. After several days in agony, wildlife officials were called in. They shot him with tranquillisers, then he died.
02:56
Officials carry dead tiger
KARMILA PARAKKASI: “It breaks my heart, because they have a right to live here and they’re even here before us.
03:29
Karmila
Somehow people just keep you know taking so much from them, first they’re taking their home, they’re taking down the forests”.
03:36
Dead tiger in truck. Fade to black.
03:45
Karmila and Brown walk over cleared land
BROWN: Tracking tigers is a dream job for this recent university graduate, but Karmila wonders how long it may last.
03:56
Sawing timber for pulp mill
And with one of the world’s biggest pulp and paper companies based here, pressure is growing. Asia Pacific Resources International Limited or APRIL is logging forest and planting acacia trees in Riau’s prime tiger territory.
04:07
Karmila and Brown walk
KARMILA PARAKKASI: “The APRIL concessions are located in different parts of the landscape and one of them is here right at the border with the Wildlife Reserve”.
BROWN: The plantations look green enough but conservationists say they’re a biological desert.
KARMILA PARAKKASI: “Before the plantation exists it was a forest, and if I were a tiger,
04:27
Karmila
I would feel sad, angry, confused
04:49
Felled timber
and I don’t know to whom I should talk to, to get back my home”.
04:54
Laurance
BILL LAURANCE: “Some of the worst forest destruction I’ve ever seen anywhere. Some of the fastest and most intense forest loss is happening there”.
05:03
Stream/Laurance walks along stream
BROWN: Now home in North Queensland, one of Australia’s most experienced forest scientists, Bill Laurance, toured Riau with APRIL earlier this year. He’s still shaken by what he saw.
BILL LAURANCE: “I thought I’d seen, you know, impressive deforestation
05:10
Laurance. Super:
Bill Laurance
Conservation biologist
in places like the eastern and southern Amazon and parts of Africa and other places, but what’s happening there on just sort of a large industrial scale is pretty daunting”.
05:28
APRIL fells trees
BROWN: As APRIL’s machines move in, they level all before them. While the company waits for its plantations to grow, the native forest provides valuable wood for its mill.
05:38
Kerr. Super:
David Kerr
Director of Operations, APRIL
DAVID KERR: “Our goal is to finish conversion as soon as we can and be a hundred per cent plantation fibre”.
05:56
APRIL fells trees
BILL LAURANCE: “Ideally, what you want to be doing is focusing on areas that have already been cleared, but when you’re going in and just mowing down vast expanses of forest, and as I understand it, it’s something in the order of about seventy thousand hectares this year, so imagine clearing a hundred and forty thousand footy fields
06:07
Laurance
of tropical rainforest just in one year to feed this giant pulp plant. I mean that’s really alarming. That’s just, it’s almost, you know, an ecological Armageddon”.
06:22
Pulp and paper mill.
Music
06:33
Logs going into hopper
BROWN: APRIL’s mill churns out more than three and a half million tons of pulp and paper each year.
06:38
Paper factory. Copy paper production line
This sprawling factory is an elaborate one-stop shop. High-grade copy paper whips along at a hundred kilometres an hour. These blocks of A4 will be familiar to many Australians. They’re on the shelves of one of our biggest office suppliers, Officeworks. Fuji Xerox sells them as well. They’ve even got a green label lauding the use of plantation wood.
06:46
BILL LAURANCE: “I think they’re greenwashing. They’re just basically trying to convince us they’re doing the right thing by the environment, but in
07:24
Laurance
fact often at times what they’re doing is pretty paltry”.
07:30
Aerial. Paper mill/Brown in helicopter with Kerr
BROWN: The view from the company’s helicopter reveals an operation of staggering size. Our tour guide is APRIL’s Director of Operations, David Kerr.
07:36
DAVID KERR: “So this is the biggest mill on the planet.
BROWN: “The biggest?”
DAVID KERR: “Yep”.
07:46
BROWN: The mill is fed by a patchwork of plantations where native forest once stood. Little is left beyond the slender fingers of forest on rivers and streams.
07:53
Burning forest
Music
08:05
BROWN: APRIL says its land management stands in stark contrast to the illegal logging and burning that scars neighbouring property.
08:08
DAVID KERR: “What we’re doing is we’re doing it in a responsible way, in line with what the Indonesian Government wants.
08:17
Kerr
If we don’t do it the way that we’re doing it, it can be even worse”.
08:26
Aerials over plantations
BROWN: “Why do you leave these single tall trees around the place?”
DAVID KERR: “It’s a requirement, a legal requirement to keep some in special species if we can, if we come across them when we’re harvesting”.
08:31
BROWN: “They look pretty lonely”.
DAVID KERR: “Yeah, they do”.
08:43
Music
08:46
Dozer fells forest trees
DAVID LAURANCE: “Mowing down vast expanses of primary forest and converting it into monocultures of exotic trees which are grown to be four, five years old and then cut down, like you cut the grass and turn into paper pulp,
08:50
Laurance. Super:
Bill Laurance
Conservation biologist
this is not something I define as environmentally sustainable. It’s something different altogether”.
09:05
Village
BROWN: Near APRIL’s mill at Kerinci the sentiment is more positive. The villagers the company introduced us to say their lives have changed for the better.
SUNGEP: “I’m very happy, because the roads are neat,
09:22
Sungep/Brown and Kerr in village
sport and education facilities are also supported by the company, and all these things are helpful for us to move forward. So we’re happy with the presence of the company that came here and cares about the community. We respect each other”.
09:35
Boat on Kampar River
BROWN: While APRIL holds out its presence in Kerinci as something of a model operation, just an hour away we find a very different story..
10:09
Aerial. Kampar Peninsula
This is the Kampar Peninsula, where it’s not just the clearing and tree felling which blights the landscape. Corruption runs as deep and murky as the Kampar River itself.
10:21
Aerial. Plantation/ Stills. Governor
Many of the companies here found a local governor only too willing to accommodate their operations for the right price
10:34
Sutjiptadi in helicopter
and if it wasn’t for a diligent local police chief named Pak Sutjiptadi a catalogue of bribes and dodgy permit deals would never have been exposed.
ZULFAHMI: “Pak Sutjiptadi at that time was unbelievable… very amazing.
10:50
Sutjiptadi on phone
He didn’t care about the controversy or pressures from everyone.
11:04
Zulfahmi. Super:
Zulfahmi
Environmentalist
Many Riau political figures and community leaders were condemning him at the time but he didn’t care”.
11:11
Sutjiptadi at pulp mill/plantation
BROWN: Sutjiptadi stunned locals like environmental activist Zulfahmi, who were used to having their concerns swept aside by powerful officials. He investigated both the big companies and their smaller suppliers.
11:21
PAK SUTJIPTADI: “Behind me is massive forest destruction which occurred as a result of wrongly obtained permits”.
11:10
Split screen. Governor’s trial
BROWN: The local governor was convicted of taking bribes in exchange for forestry concessions. He’d even cashed a cheque for a quarter of a million dollars, written by APRIL’s Indonesian subsidiary.
11:47
Kerr. Super:
David Kerr
Director of Operations, APRIL
DAVID KERR: “I’m not aware of that incident, but I will say that we run this company with the highest standards of corporate governance and we don’t stand for any of our employees being involved in any illegal activities”.
12:04
Stacked logs/ Sutjiptadi at pulp mill/plantation
BROWN: APRIL says the cheque was made out to one of its suppliers to pay for a shipment of wood and the company did not authorise it to be used in any other way, but the exact role of APRIL’s subsidiary and the other companies was never properly examined. The police chief was suddenly transferred and his successor shut down the investigation citing a lack of evidence.
12:17
Zulfahmi
ZULFAHMI: “It was like destroying our hopes. We were disappointed, sad, furious all mixed. Not only me, but a lot of Riau people”.
12:51
Kampar River
BROWN: When a Presidential task force looked into the scandal in March this year, it was concerned enough to urge the police to re-examine the companies involved.
13:04
Brown on river, to camera. Super: Matt Brown
While the government officials have been gaoled, the companies have still got their plantations just behind this tree line, and their seeds of corruption will probably still grow into healthy profits.
13:15
Nando and Brown in forest
13:28
Community leader, Jasri Nando, grew up on the Kampar River and watched as the once familiar landscape was
13:36
Cleared forest
turned into this.
JASRI NANDO: “In the beginning, everybody was against it. But after the company perhaps offered a gain,
13:43
Nando
everyone with power embraced the company one by one”.
13:54
Nando and Brown in forest
BROWN: Nando is taking us to one of the striking remnants of the original forest.
14:02
Huge tree in forest
JASRI NANDO: “We were born here, and we don’t want to lose the nature”.
BROWN: It’s a beautiful monument to what’s been lost.
14:12
Nando
JASRI NANDO: “I’m angry. But nobody cares that I’m angry. Who will listen?”
14:23
Huge tree in forest
BROWN: This tree marks another extraordinary feature of the Kampar Peninsula – its roots burrow down into deep wet carbon-rich peat.
14:32
Cortesi and Brown look at map
Lafcadio Cortesi from the Rainforest Action Network warns logging on the peat risks a greenhouse gas disaster.
14:48
Super:
Lafcadio Cortesi
Rainforest Action Network
LAFCADIO CORTESI: “They’re these huge banks or reservoirs of carbon that has been accumulating over, certainly thousands, and maybe even tens of thousands of years”.
14:59
Aerial. Deforestation/Canals
BROWN: APRIL’s plantations can’t thrive in the damp peat, so the company digs canals to drain off the water and when the peat dries, it releases great clouds of greenhouse gas.
LAFCADIO CORTESI: “We’re seeing hundreds of thousands of hectares of deep peat being converted to plantations. Indonesia is the world’s third largest greenhouse gas emitter and that is coming not from smoke stacks, it’s coming from the conversion of these forests and these peat lands which are emitting massive amounts of carbon.
15:08
Lafcadio
So there’s a lot at stake”.
15:48
Aerial. Forest
BROWN: APRIL is only preserving the most sensitive site, at the centre of the Peninsular. The area is known as the “peat dome” where the peat is the deepest.
15:51
Kerr and Brown in forest
DAVID KERR: “In English it stands for Orchid Lake and it’s high value conservation area that we’ve actually expanded around it, because it’s a special place for us – lots of biodiversity, buffered by our acacia plantations and thriving naturally in the bush”.
16:09
Dams
BROWN: APRIL says it’s protecting this delicate eco system by building new dams on its canals to stop the peat from draining too fast.
DAVID KERR: “Overall it’s the real world solution in terms of keeping
16:30
Kerr
the high conservation value areas intact and establishing sustainability for our company.
16:43
Lafcadio
LAFCADIO CORTESI: “The bottom line is that they’re going to be lowering the water levels and how that impacts the whole dome, the whole ecosystem is really anyone’s guess”.
16:50
Aerial. Over Malacca Strait
BROWN: As its appetite for fresh forests and new plantations grows, APRIL is spreading its operations out into the Malacca Strait between Sumatra and Singapore.
17:02
Travelling to Pulau Padang by boat
We’re on our way to the small peat topped island of Pulau Padang. The mountains of logs on barges are an omen of the island’s fate.
17:18
On motorbikes on Pulau Padang
Palau Padang has a small but thriving economy with locals making a living out of rubber and sago.
17:35
Sago factory
Sago factories hug the coastline and sell the extracted starch to the mainland.
17:42
Pairan cutting sago palm
PAIRAN: “I have this dream - for the next generation – for my kids especially”.
17:59
BROWN: Pairan’s family has lived and farmed sago on the island for six generations.
18:07
Pairan
PAIRAN: “I don’t want my family to have a mediocre life. My goal is to become advanced so that my family’s needs can be met”.
18:14
Pairan walks with family
BROWN: Pairan says his hopes and ambitions are under threat because his sago farm is in APRIL’s new concession. Although he has longstanding deeds granted by the local government, that doesn’t matter. He’s been told the company’s concession trumps the lot.
PAIRAN: “I feel very upset and very sad and I can’t imagine what will happen to my family.
18:32
Pairan
[upset] I can’t imagine…I would be able…to continue educating my kids because the only thing that I have – my only hope – is my land”.
19:06
Land clearing on coast
BROWN: APRIL is already chopping its way inland.
19:40
Brown on boat
On the island’s most remote coast it’s carving a swathe through the forest preparing for more roads and canals.
19:44
Security at land clearing
It is little wonder security is tight. Tensions here are mounting.
19:53
Villagers rally on motorbikes
Twelve of the fourteen village heads here have agreed to APRIL’s plans, but hundreds have turned out today to peacefully rally against their governor’s decision to grant APRIL more than a third of the island.
20:09
Pairan and family on motorbike at rally
PAIRAN: “I’m the sixth generation of my family who was born on this island. I will not let anyone take away my rights. I will defend my farm with my life. Whatever happens, I will stand in the middle of my farm. I will defend it if the company tries to take away my rights”.
20:26
Rally gathers at mosque
BROWN: They’re gathering at their local mosque to pray for their future.
21:03
Man at mosque speaks to rally members
MAN AT MOSQUE: “Ask the God Almighty that we are always given strength…so that we are always united – to fight what we’ve been fighting all along against the presence of the company on this island”.
21:10
Rally members at mosque
BROWN: According to APRIL the people of Pulau Padang have nothing to fear and instead, it’s offering them a bright future.
DAVID KERR: “The solution for those people
21:34
may be that they still can get to their land. The solution for other people in that area may be that they can end up working for us”.
21:44
Brown leaves island on boat
BROWN: Despite those assurances the conflict turned violent. Two days after we left Pulau Padang contractors clearing the land for APRIL were attacked at night. Their machines were bombed and one man was stabbed and burned to death.
21:55
Pairan with family
With growing concerns about community conflicts and the logging of natural forests, last year the internationally recognised organisation for good forest management, the Forest Stewardship Council, suspended APRIL’s accreditation.
22:21
Pairan
PAIRAN: “I suggest to all people in this world, please don’t use paper wastefully.
22:38
Pairan with family
And I hope all people in this world work to save the Earth, save the forests, and small islands such as our Padang Island”.
22:50
Deforestation
BROWN: While Australia debates its carbon future, Australians are buying ream after ream of paper made in the greenhouse gas capital of Indonesia. And the Sumatran forests, people and tigers are paying the price.
BILL LAURANCE: “When I came back from Sumatra,
23:21
Bill Laurance
I almost felt like I had a little bit of post traumatic stress. I mean I just felt at some gut level really disturbed.
23:42
It’s just the sense that there’s an environmental travesty ongoing here and it’s just alarming to sit here and watch it happening right before your eyes”.
23:53
23:59
Credits:
Reporter: Matt Brown
Editor: Nick Brenner
Camera: David Anderson
David Martin
Research: Ake Prihantari
Ari Wuryantama
Dede Kunaifi
Producer: Mary Ann Jolley
24:05