00.20 | KUTI ROYKAEW teacher in a boat from Chiang Khong, on theThai side of Mekong River | When I go down to the Mekong river I saw many many people who use Mekong river for life. It is a very bad situation in the Mekong now |
| ||||
00.41
| Ms Souvanna Boutamong Lao Ecologist on the Mekong River near Vientiane in Laos
| People should pay more attention and concern about how to protect the Mekong river. The Mekong river is lower and lower. |
| ||||
01.20 | Water sprouting from Xiaowan Dam on the Chinese section of the Mekong | In March 2010 the river reached its lowest level in 50 years .Could the major cause be found in man’s attempt to conquer nature,to tame the rapids and roar of the Mekong with a cascade of dams ? |
| ||||
01.34 | Titles | WHERE HAVE ALL THE FISH GONE?
|
| ||||
|
| KILLING THE MEKONG DAM BY DAM |
| ||||
01.43 | Views : The Mekong mountains in Tibet to the delta in Vietnam
| The Mekong. One of the great rivers of the world. Coursing through six countries, from its source high in the Himalayas of Tibet, 4900 kilometres long, Its journey ends in the Mekong delta of Vietnam Rich in fisheries, wildlife, dolphins and extraordinary biodiversity. this is the Amazon of South East Asia. |
| ||||
02.08
| KUTI ROYKAEW Interview
| In Mekong River give everything food give culture for life when you have no food, you can get food from the Mekong vegetables herbs, everythingand it is very important that Mekong river is mother. I think Mekong is the same as mother |
| ||||
02.44 | Boat in Kratie Cambodia | But dark clouds are gathering. A storm of controversy hangs over the future of this great river. Black clouds beckon. The Mekong is moving towards a huge dam building programme. Will the river become devastated by dams? |
| ||||
3.03 | Huaneng office of Xiaowan dam company in Kunming CHINA
| A cascade of dams and reservoirs are being planned in the boardrooms of Chinese hydro-power corporations, Thai companies, and other developers which could change the Mekong for ever.. |
| ||||
| Chinese office of dam company Sinohydro Karnchang MegaFirst –Thai /Malaysian dam developers and development banks | To Chinese Thai and Malaysian companies, development banks technocrats and business lobbies: the Mekong is the dream of hydropower potential for an energy-hungry region. |
| ||||
3.27
| Thai fisherman on the Mekong near Chiang Saen Thailand
Fishermen
Crocodile forest plants Biodiversity and the ecosystem | But to the fishermen, small farmers, millions of villagers along the Mekong, this taming of the raging torrents with a cascade of dams, is not a dream. This developer’s dream is a fisherman ’s nightmare. 65 million people in this region are dependent for food and livelihood on a healthy Mekong that long sustained their ancestors. If the fast flowing currents are transformed into still reservoirs, the Mekong will be transformed into a devastated ecosystem. |
| ||||
4.00
| forest plants nature |
|
| ||||
4.09
| Ms Souvanna Bouttamong Lao environmental researcher | Because the life depends on the Mekong River, and it not only affects Lao people. And not only Vientiane in the centre of Laos but up to north Laos, depends on fish from the Mekong . |
| ||||
4.25 | KUTI ROYKAEW leader of Chiang Khong Conservation group
| Kuti is a teacher and environmental activist in Chiang Khong on the Thai side of the Mekong.He has he has educated 55 communities in a lively campaign to save the Mekong |
| ||||
4.40 | KUIT ROYKAEW
| upper Mekong have a dam in China. Have problem many problems |
| ||||
4.47 | XIAOWAN DAM completed in September 2010. | The gigantic Xiaowan dam at 292 metres high, is the world’s tallest high arch dam ,nearly as high as the the top of the Eiffel Tower in Paris |
| ||||
| Music Xiaowan Dam |
|
| ||||
| Narration
| Its vast reservoir covers an area of 190 square kilometres
|
| ||||
5.30 | YAO WEN First secretary of Chinese embassy Bangkok | the question of dams does not affect the water flow of the Lancing river, so it does not affect the water flow of the Mekong [ note: Lancang is the Chinese name for Mekong River ] |
| ||||
5.36 |
Narration |
Australian Mekong specialist Philip Hirsch has a very different assessment of this dam |
| ||||
5.44 | Dr Philip Hirsch Director of the Australian Mekong Research Centre University of Sydney [The Nuozhadu dam is under construction] | The Xiaowan and the Nuozhadu, are of a completely different order. these dams are going to fundamentally and permanently affect the hydrological flow of the Mekong all the way through the system |
| ||||
6.02 | KUTI ROYKAEW demonstration outside Chinese embassy in Bangkok speaking in Thai Subtiles | Thai teacher Kuti points out that China has not changed its policy at all. sub-titles If China does not respond to our demands we promise we will be back in front of the embassy |
| ||||
6.18 | Narration | China still plans to build four more dams without any consultation with the communities that live downstream |
| ||||
6.25 | MAP OF DAMS narration | The headlong rush of hydropower plans to build more dams continues. China plans to have 8 dams. On the lower Mekong 11 more dams are being promoted in Laos and Cambodia |
| ||||
6.42 | Dr JUHA SAARKULA FINNISH INSITUTUTE OF THE ENVIRONMENT | I would really proposed to slow down the pace and take a time-out to look at the feasibility of the whole process and consider alternative developments
|
|
| |||
6.55 | SIPHANDONE - LAOS FOUR THOUSAND ISLANDS
narration
| How is it possible that a company could even consider erecting a dam, only a few kilometres away from the rapturous beauty of the Khone Waterfall in Laos . ?
Siphandon district of Laos is known as four thousand islands. A pristine wonder of nature,it is central to the development of Laos as a ecotourism leader in the region. |
| ||||
08.08 | MEGAFIRST COMPANY SIGN MAP OF MEKONG ISLANDS AND THE HOU SAHONG CHANNEL | Malaysian company Megafirst plans to build a dam right here
|
| ||||
08.15 | Ms SOUVANNA BOUTTAMONG | Lao Cambodia Vietnam and Thailand all depend on Hou Sahong. The fish migrate from upstream to downstream. and from downstream to upstream. If they block this channel, I am not sure we will get fish to eat anymore. The food security. The peoples’ lives and peoples’ future, all depend on Hou Sahong.
|
| ||||
8.06 |
| the Lao government is not conducting any studies on this project..So the Lao government has to rely purely on the information provided by the company, which essentially means you have the fox guarding the hen-house
|
| ||||
8.11 | MAP OF DON SAHONG DAM SITE ACROSS THE HOU SAHONG CHANNEL Narration | The Don Sahong dam project and two more dams in across the border in Cambodia - in Stung Treng and Sambor would be the final blow to the survival of Mekong’s dolphin population |
| ||||
8.40 | GORDON CONGDON representativeWWF (WorldWildlife Fund) Kratie Cambodia
| This is the last remaining habitat of the Irrawaddy dolphin in the Mekong..A dam anywhere on the Mekong would have a probably devastating effect.The Irrawaddy Dolphin has long been an almost sacred animal, certainly a revered animal in Cambodia |
| ||||
8.40 | Dr So Nam Director of Institute of Fisheries Cambodia
| Cambodian people totally depend on fisheries in consumption and protein intake in their daily diet. It is worth $250 million dollars at the landing site and provides 30% of agricultural products. It accounts for 8-12% of Cambodia’s GDP. It is very high The fisheries sector is very important for nutrition, economy, employment, in terms of biodiversity and also tourism . |
| ||||
9.33 | CAMBODIAN DATA FISHERIES CONSUMPTION graphic |
|
| ||||
9.40 | GORDON CONGDON WWF KRATIE CAMBODIA | The people in Cambodia and the agriculture are adapted to a river that floods nearly every year . The floods bring the water necessary to irrigate the rice fields. The floods also bring sediment and nutrients essential to maintaining the fertility of the soil. If this cycle of flooding is somehow controlled or interrupted by even by a relatively small degree, it could potentially have a enormous impact on agriculture and food security in Cambodia . |
| ||||
10.16 | IMAGE OF FISH |
|
| ||||
10.20 | CONGDON WWF interview continued | The fisheries of the Mekong . the most productive and important in the world, largely depends on that flood-pulse that comes every year. |
| ||||
10.30 | GORDON CONGDON WWF
MAP OF TONLE SAP TONLE SAP LAKE CAMBODIA FLOATING FOREST SEQUENCE
| as you know there is this remarkable phenomenon where the river that connects with Tonle Sap the great Cambodian lake with the Mekong. The Tonle Sap river reverses its flow every year when the Mekong is high, and the water flows into the Tonle Sap the water in the lake expands 4-5 times its normal size the fish go out into the flooded forest and breed This lake then becomes an incredibly productive nursery for the fisheries |
| ||||
11.11 | GORDON CONGDON WWF
| The fish then come back down the river back into the Mekong, and migrate up the river as far as Thailand |
| ||||
11.17 | NY SAN Cambodian ngo consultant
| According to that study there is a thousand fish species along the Mekong, and the majority of fish species need to migrate in order to give birth to new fish . |
| ||||
11.33 | GORDON CONGDON | Any minor modification to the hydrology of the Mekong puts this incredible system at risk. |
| ||||
11.38 | TONLE SAP SEQUENCE FISH AND BOATS | And at risk is the greatest inland fisheries in the world, which is catching around 3.9million tons of fish a year, valued at nearly 3 billion dollars. |
| ||||
11.58 | JEREMY BIRD former CEO MEKONG RIVER COMISSION
| This a river basin that has the largest inland fisheries in the world , and second in biodiversity after the Amazon. The fisheries is the number one issue to be solved. And the onus for demonstrating that this can be solved rests with the promoters of the project
|
| ||||
12.15 | near the Xayaburi dam-site on the Mekong
narration | The Xayaboury dam in Laos is slated to be the first mainstream dam on the Mekong outside of China.This dam could become a test case for the future dam development on the Mekong |
| ||||
12.19 | DR PHILIP HIRSCH
image of the endangered species the Giant Catfish unique to the Mekong. | The Xayaburi Dam is highly significant as the first dam - if it goes ahead ---to be built on the mainstream of the Mekong outside of China...it is significant in its own right . The World Wildlife fund recently issued a report that the Giant catfish -the iconic fish of the Mekong, will become extinct if the Xayaburi dam goes ahead, and 41 other species that are likely to go extinct. if the Xayaburi goes ahead It opens the flood -gates (excuse the pun) for all the other dams to get approval –once they have got Xayaburi , they have got the lot !
|
| ||||
| KUTI ROYKAEW | music |
| ||||
12.57 | KUTI ROYKAEW Interview on the Mekong | Xayaburi dam is a dangerous building for the people on the Mekong river. Everybody want to money from Mekong river. They want to make dam for electric(hydropower) .Easy to make money. Easy! |
| ||||
13.19 | Graphic dam and the 4 Thai banks The Bangkok Bank 2)The Siam Commercial Bank 3)Kasikorn bank 4) Krung Thai bank CH. KARNCHANG LOGO
| This 3.5 billion dollar project for the Xayaburi dam is funded by 4 biggest Thai banks .95% of the electricity willl be sold to Thailand. The dam-builder Bangkok’s CH.Karnchang corporation plans to make a handsome profit. . |
| ||||
13.42 | narration Dam protest in Bangkok
| The opposition is growing among the citizens of the Mekong. They demand the dam-builders respect the international nature of this river and the rights of the citizens of the Mekong shared by six nations |
| ||||
13.53 | Chhit Sam Ath NGO forum | I think that development has different dimensions. If you are talking about infrastructure development you can be talking about a bridge or a dam . also many development projects are about improving the livelihood of the poor and vulnerable groups. You have to think about development for whom? It is important for the developer or the government to answer this question. Who will benefit from th 16.05 | DANG THUY TRANG WWF World Wildlife Fund Mekong Coordinator
| I think Vietnam has a very very big stake. we have to consider how important the Mekong delta is in terms of the economy of the whole country.. Also in biodiversity we have the greatest number of fish species in the whole Mekong river. Biodiversity is important, fisheries is very important agriculture is extremely important, especially in rice production. Vietnam is the second largest rice exporter in the world ,so now if there is a dam put in the river -it is blocking sediment. And it is not just the quantity of the sediment. It is also the quality of the sediment that is important. And that may completely change the ecosystem of the Mekong.
|
| ||
16.56 | NGUYEN HONG PHUONG member of the VNMC The Vietnam National Mekong Committee |
. The effect of the cascade of dams can be massive. A disaster to the Mekong people. So the people in the Mekong delta share that .It could be a disaster for their lives
|
| ||||
17.09 | DANG THUY TRANG WWF
| Vietnam’s point of view seems to be very clear. We think it is reasonable to call for this 10 year delay of the Xayaburi dam |
| ||||
17.20 | NATIONAL PARLIAMENT VIETNAM | music |
| ||||
17.20 | DOCUMENT STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW commissioned by the MRC Xiaowan Dam
| Vietnam fully endorsed the Strategic Environmental Review, a special study on the impact of dams on future of the Mekong . The review recommended: No more dams should be built for at least 10 years. |
| ||||
17.34 | THANH NIEN newspaper Headline ‘Damn Those Dams |
|
| ||||
17.36 | HUN SEN MEETS VIETNAMESE PM NGUYEN TAN DUNG | The two prime ministers from Cambodian and Vietnam held a summit meeting in April 2011 in Phnom Penh. They called on the Lao government to delay the Xayaburi Dam project |
| ||||
17.50 | Dr HIRSCH
| They also said in their statement that dam projects on the Mekong including Xayaburi should be put on hold for at least ten years. The Lao government committed to do a review of the process |
| ||||
18.10 | Dr KRAISAK CHOONHAVAN photo :Bhumiphol Dam Thailand | there are too many dams already in Thailand so they can never build a dam in Thailand anymore. So companies like Ch.Karnchang go to Laos to build big dams |
| ||||
18.23 | narration
| Even while the decision on the Xayaburi Dam was supposed to be under review by the Lao government, Ch Karnchang wasted no time in building a road to the dam-site. Their message was clear. The international consultations and agreements of the Mekong River Commission were irrelevant
|
| ||||
18.40 | Dr KRAISAK CHOONHAVAN Choonhavan Karnchang building a road to dam- site | We have called them but they did not come to the parliament . Ch.Karchang does not respect the law in Thailand, nor its obligations to the parliament. |
| ||||
18.54 | Karnchang logo Dr Philip Hirsch Mekong Research Centre Australia | Ch. Karnchang is a construction company. It is there to make a profit for its shareholders. As far as I am aware it has not signed up to any code of corporate social responsibility |
| ||||
19.04 | Dr KRAISAK CHOONHAVAN | Ch Karnchang operates without environmental studies or when they do it , they do it very poorly. They don’t feel compelled to do a comprehensive one |
| ||||
19.17 | Dr PHILIP HIRSCH | And therefore If they are told they can go ahead and build a dam, then they will go ahead and build dam. .They take a narrow view that we are only responsible to our shareholders, we are there to a profit, no matter what it may cost the river, no matter what is may cost other countries, whatever it may cost people who live along the river .Their own bottom-line is if they can get away with it ,they will .
|
| ||||
| POYRY SEGMENT |
|
| ||||
19.45 | Buddist monks and others arching against Xayaburi dam | Mounting protests against the Xayaburi Dam prompted the Lao government to hire an international consultant Poyry Energy based in Zurich. Poyry, the Lao government and the Thai dam –builder Ch. Karnchang had been working together on the Nam Ngum2 dam in Laos. The Poyry Report with the focus on whether the dam complied with the Mekong River Commission guidelines on dams, gave a green light to the dam-bulders. It provided a stamp of approval for the Lao government to launch the Xayaburi dam |
| ||||
20.17 | Dr Jian Hua Meng Hydropower advisor working for WWF | German-trained civil engineer Dr Jian Hua Meng is the WWF advisor on hydropower |
| ||||
20.25 | DR.JIAN-HUA MENG
|
The consultant this Finnish-Swiss company advised the developer to go ahead in spite of the concerns.The compliance report has no credibility with other MRC countries and development partners, because It was done unilaterally and commissioned to the Ministry of Industry and Energy in Laos. This was completely outside MRC process ,It was merely a commercial consultant report by a company looking for contracts.” |
| ||||
21.08 |
| The dam was launched. Poyry Energy found their contract. They were handsomely rewarded with an 8 year contract to supervise the dam design and the engineering |
| ||||
21.20 | PIANPORN DEETES | The Thai villagers in 8 Mekong provinces in north and north-east submitted a letter to Thai environmental minister to urge him to take a position not to buy electricity from the Xayaburi dam and to halt the power purchase agreement between Thai utility Egat and Ch Karnchang company . |
| ||||
21.45
| narration | Thailand will buy 95% of the electricity from the dam. Mekong villagers and. Ngos have filed a case in the Thai courts to stop the contract. |
| ||||
21.57 | HELSINKI FINLAND | Poyry, the parent company in Helsinki, is under investigation by a government-backed tribunal. |
| ||||
22.06 | Luiisa Ummonen | Poyry gave badly misleading advice and helped the Lao government to push through its devastating plans to dam the Mekong at Xayaburi against the 1995 Mekong Agreement.” |
| ||||
22.20 | Dr Jian | This is not how corporate responisible industry players should perform
|
| ||||
| LOGO OF OECD | The government insists that companies should adhere to Europe‘s OECD rules of corporate social responsibility, both at home and abroad. |
| ||||
22.38 | Luiisa Ummonen | by placing the ambitions of Poyry above the spirit of cooperation in the Mekong agreement,Poyry has chosen to also place the livelihoods of millions of people in danger. This is unacceptable.” |
| ||||
22.55 | narration | Poyry has denied all these accusations |
| ||||
| POYRY ENERGY DENIAL | . “We would like to stress that Pöyry has no conflict of interest in the Xayaburi project. It was natural that we were willing to continue in the project, since this way we can best supervise our recommendations [as consultant ]that will be implemented.” Petteri Härkki President of Pöyry Energy Asia in Bangkok |
| ||||
23.16 |
| MRC experts found may flaws in the 2011 Poyry report |
| ||||
23.38 | Dr Jian-Hua Meng | .some of them are very very fundamental but then oddly enough the report recommends to go ahead and build the dam and fix problems on the way. You don’t get on a plane while you are still are uncertain about how to design it or how to land it. |
| ||||
|
| POYRY assured diplomats the latest technology would provide Over 80% mitigation for the fish.But many scientists like Dr Meng, dismiss these claims |
| ||||
| ZURICH SWTIZERLAND image High rise buildings and Credit Suisse bank | In Switzerland fish ladders only deal with a small number of species, whereas the Mekong is teeming with hundreds of different fish. |
| ||||
23.59 | DR JIAN HUA MENG | building a fish pass based on experiences of northern Europe Switzerland and transferring them to the Mekong to a large tropical river is just not serious business. This dam which is so benign so they claim, that it is virtually not there.This is basically nonsense. It is plain ridiculous. This is a fairy-tale ,a sales trick set into the eyes of inexperienced political decision-makers. It is basically a honey –trail for political decision-makers |
| ||||
|
| THE DAM CONSTRUCTION HAS STARTED |
| ||||
24.50 | THE RISK OF EARTHQUAKES |
|
| ||||
24.53 | image: earthquake 2011 in Tachilek northern Burma opposite Mae Sai on Thai side of the border
| In a world of increasing natural disasters , building dams on sites prone to earthquakes is a major concern The March 24th 2011 earthquake in Myanmar also inflicted damage on northern Thailand and Laos as Dr Sampan a Thai expert on earthquakes explains |
| ||||
25.13
| DR SAMPAN SINGHARAJWARAPAN Seismologist Department of Geography Chiangmai University | that earthquake was a quite a big one for Thailand and people in that region. It recorded 6.8 on the Richter scale, which is pretty big.
|
| ||||
25.27
|
earthquake footage |
this terrible destruction occurred only a few hundred kilometers from where the Thai company Ch.Karchchang is determined to build a dam |
| ||||
25.37 | Dr Sampan Singharajwaranpan | Even In that area,the Xayaburi area a lot of big earthquakes occurred already. Recently there was 6.3 on the Richter scale 4-5 a few years ago, so that indicates it is earthquake prone and so that is a bit of a worry |
| ||||
26.01 | Dr Sampan Singharajwaranpan
TSUNAMI 2004 FOOTAGE
| If the dam is going to be hit by the earthquake bigger than what they had thought, then if the dam collapses, there is going to be a kind of inland Tsunami! The floodwater could rise to about 20 metres high
|
| ||||
26.15 | Narration
Karnchang road-building
| Dams on the Mekong threaten a mad-made disaster that could destroy the food security. The earthquakes only add to the dangers and concerns about hydropower |
| ||||
26.28 | Dr JIAN-HUA MENG
| Now the developer wants all the stakeholders to follow him blindly while taking a leap of faith into an uncertain future and watch them take a very risky game of roulette based on biased advice. Now the stakes for 60 million people are too high. This is just very very high risk to go ahead |
| ||||
27.02 | Narration
| If the Xayaburi Dam goes` ahead, the Giant catfish already endangered will soon pass into the realm of the extinct. .Many species of migratory fish will die out and a unique ecosystem is doomed.
Can the world allow the gradual killing of the mighty Mekong , dam by dam?
|
| ||||
27.31 | Dr Kraisak Choonhavan
| The Mekong river should be a river without dams. A river that should give life and biodiversity from China, all the way down to the sea. There should be no dams no dams at all
|
| ||||
27.50 | Ms Souvanna Bouttamong Lao ecologist | Fisherman say more dams less fish. Local people say dams bring development project dam – brings brightness In the eyes, but darkness in their heart. For People born on the Mekong, the river is like their blood, the principle of life. If the Mekong is destroyed or damaged, I will be sad. |
| ||||
28.28 | Narration | Will the children of the future be asking : Where have all the fish gone? |
| ||||
|
| CREDITS THE END |
| ||||