POST
PRODUCTION
SCRIPT
FOREIGN
CORRESPONDENT
2016
Afghanistan
– On Thin Ice
25
mins 06 secs
©2016
ABC
Ultimo Centre
700
Harris Street Ultimo
NSW 2007
Australia
GPO Box
9994
Sydney
NSW 2001
Australia
Phone: 61 2 8333 4383
Fax: 61 2 8333 4859
e-mail thompson.haydn@abc.net.au
Precis |
Aspen it is not. No chair lifts means skiers must trudge
through knee-deep snow up to the top of the mountain. Local kids fashion skis
from roughly hewn chunks of wood. And you can forget about après-ski. |
|
|
This is skiing Afghanistan-style, in central Bamiyan
province, drawcard for a handful of adventurous westerners and a hardy band
of locals. |
|
|
It’s pretty surreal to be here. You just have to stop for
a second and appreciate the moment.
– Jeff Olson, a snowboarding lawyer from Texas |
|
|
The skiers know their joy could be short lived. Heavily
armed police patrol the ski slopes in a constant reminder of a lurking threat
from the Taliban just over the mountains. |
|
|
So far, the snow-capped ranges that ring Bamiyan have
helped to keep the Taliban out. But the Taliban is on the march in the rest
of the country, and they have Bamiyan in their sights when the snows thaw. |
|
|
They’ve been there before. Few could forget their
destruction of Bamiyan’s “un-Islamic” 6th century giant Buddhas in 2001
– 1500 years of history obliterated
just months before the twin towers fell in New York. |
|
|
Bamiyan is also the stronghold and ancestral home of the
Hazara people, a persecuted minority who are Shia Muslims -- infidels in the
eyes of the Sunni Taliban. |
|
|
I remember three of my uncles – they took them from their
shops and lined them up with more than 300 people and shot them. – Hazara man Jawad Lakoo, on life under the Taliban in
the 1990s |
|
|
Now the Hazara of Bamiyan are on edge, wondering when the
Taliban will next come after them. |
|
|
They will start killing Hazara people again, just as they
did before. – Hazara woman skier Zakia, 21 |
|
|
Many Hazara are thinking of fleeing, but for now locals
and tourists enjoy the distractions of the races at the annual Afghan Ski
Challenge. The winner, local mechanic Shah Aqa, savours the moment. |
|
|
Skiing sends a message of peace and unity. It’s special
for Bamiyan. – Shah Aqa |
|
|
It’s a message that may be
lost on the Taliban. |
|
Snowy mountain landscape |
Music
|
00:00 |
Kids skiing |
|
00:05 |
Kids hiking up muddy path to
ski area SUPER:
Bamiyan, Afghanistan |
BENNETT:
The snow is patchy. Equipment...? Basic. But the enthusiasm is abundant.
Welcome to skiing, Afghan style. |
00:14 |
People downhill skiing -- Afghan
ski challenge SUPER: ON THIN ICE Reporter: James Bennett |
Music
|
00:30 |
|
BENNETT: In a nation wracked by violence, lies a
place that still offers that rarest of commodities – peace. |
00:47 |
|
Music
|
00:54 |
|
BENNETT: It’s an hour up and five minutes down in
the 6th annual Afghan ski challenge. |
01:02 |
|
Music
|
01:10 |
Olsen climbing to top of ski
run |
JEFF
OLSON: “Absolutely broken. It’s a really tough climb, much harder than I
expected”. |
01:13 |
|
Music
|
01:21 |
Finish line |
BENNETT:
The field comprises a few adventurous westerners with a horde of hardy
locals, well acclimatised to the lung tearing kilometre long climb to the
top. |
01:25 |
Olson 100% |
JEFF
OLSON: “It was really funny, you know, struggling up the hill, you know,
sucking wind just absolutely dying |
01:37 |
Kids walking uphill |
and
then you see these little Afghan kids, skis over their shoulders, just
breaking trail straight up the mountain and |
01:42 |
Olson 100% |
you
just have to, you know, chuckle about it”. |
01:49 |
Skiing GVs |
Music
|
01:51 |
|
BENNETT:
The race was conceived and is still run by European ski enthusiasts working
in Kabul. Locals have taken up the challenge with passion, even if there’s
still not quite enough donated ski equipment to go around. |
01:56 |
Bennett skis |
Music
|
02:09 |
Bennett to camera |
BENNETT: “Well that’s all a tremendous amount of
fun, a lot of hard work especially having to go up under your own steam. The
Governor here wants to put a ski lift in to make that easier and obviously
there’s a lot of people here that would be keen for that, but the Taliban are
just over these hills and it does all beg the question of whether all of this
will be here tomorrow”. |
02:19 |
Kids and adults skiing |
Bamiyan
is the ancestral home of the Hazara people, a Shia Islam minority making up
about 10% of Afghanistan’s population. The Sunni majority Taliban regard them
as infidels to be subjugated and massacred. |
02:38 |
|
The
mountains, as high as 5,000 metres, shield them from a resurgent Taliban who
await the spring thaw. For now, the Hazara focus on transforming this place
into an international adventure tourism venue. But fear of the escalating
conflict means that like this year’s snow, foreign visitors are thin on the
ground. |
03:08 |
Olson 100%. Super: |
JEFF
OLSON: “You get here and you kind of forget all that when you just see, you
know, people hanging about, having a good time, participating in a ski race.
Everybody’s really warm and welcoming and friendly and so it feels very
normal actually when you’re here, you know, compared to what you see on the
news when you’re away but yeah, I mean you just pause and think and it’s
pretty surreal to be here”. |
03:39 |
Olson prepares for ski
challenge |
BENNETT:
Texan lawyer Jeff Olson caught the snowboarding bug a couple of years ago and
happened across Afghanistan surfing the web for exotic slopes. JEFF
OLSON: “You know, you see the military guys |
04:00 |
Hazara military security at
event |
down
here and, you know, you think about where you are and what you’re doing and
it’s just incredible. You just have to stop |
04:18 |
Olson 100% |
and
pause for a second and you know appreciate the moment”. |
04:23 |
Guy falls over at finish
line |
|
04:26 |
Hazara military/Skiing GVs |
BENNETT:
Today at least, these Hazara military guys appear suitably chilled. Attacks
here are rare - but the situation in the rest of the country is increasingly
grim as the Taliban seize large swathes of countryside. JEFF
OLSON: “You know, you think about, you know, what it is we’re doing here and
you know what makes it possible and how quickly it could turn in to be
impossible |
04:31 |
Olson 100% |
if
the situation changes, and just really how delicate the balance, you know, is
still in this country. |
04:59 |
Shah
Aqa wins trophy |
BENNETT:
Living fully in the moment the ski crowd celebrates the win of Shah Aqa, a
young mechanic from a local village. CROWD: [cheers] |
05:05 |
Shah Aqa 100% |
SHAH
AQA: “Skiing sends a message of peace and unity. It’s special for Bamiyan,
because skiing only began here in the last few years”. |
05:23 |
Kids on tank |
Music
|
05:33 |
Musicians in cafe |
|
05:41 |
Bamiyan
[see
program end for map patch to accompany voice over] |
BENNETT:
Located on the ancient Silk route, Bamiyan is the capital of Bamiyan Province
and lies about 240 km northwest of Kabul. |
05:48 |
Bamiyan streets GV |
Music |
06:03 |
Hazaras on streets of
Bamiyan |
BENNETT: According to legend, the Hazara descended
from Genghis Khan’s Mongol hordes that swept all before them in their
conquest of Eurasia. Their distinctively Asian appearance sets them apart
from other Afghans. At home that helps them spot the predominantly ethnic
Pashtun Taliban that venture out and they’re easy targets for the extremist
Sunni insurgents. |
06:09 |
|
Music
|
06:34 |
Scenic Bamiyan shots. Site
of destroyed Buddhas |
BENNETT: Long before skiing, the Hazara were
custodians of a great treasure, the famed Buddhas of Bamiyan, dating back to
the 6th century AD. |
06:43 |
|
Music
|
06:55 |
File footage 2001.
Destruction of Buddhas |
BENNETT: 1,500 years of history was obliterated
when in early 2001, Afghanistan’s Taliban rulers declared the Buddhas to be
un-Islamic. |
07:00 |
Present day site |
Looming
large over Bamiyan today are two gaping reminders of where the great icons of
Hazara identity once stood. |
07:19 |
|
TOUR
GUIDE: The lower caves over the years were used for |
07:29 |
Guided tour at site |
local
people for animal feed, they’d shelter in there and they’d build fires. But
some of the high rooms still have plasterwork and some of the paintings from
1,500 years ago”. |
07:33 |
|
BENNETT:
Guided tours of the world’s hot spots are becoming big business, but even for
this new breed of adventurers, Afghanistan is regarded as an extreme
destination. |
07:47 |
Lisa 100% |
“What
did your friends think when you said you were off to…” LISA
FUERST: [laughing] “Well I’ve been here before so they weren’t completely
shocked. You know, I have some friends who are... they’re like, oh my gosh I
wish I could come with you. And other friends who think I’m insane”. |
08:04 |
Lisa on guided tour |
BENNETT:
On tour with Texan Jeff Olson is New York financial analyst, Lisa Fuerst. |
08:17 |
|
LISA
FUERST: [adventure tourist] “I think there’s a term in the States called “war
tourism” or something like that and that’s not what I’m coming for. I mean I
have no interest in going around and seeing bombed out cities and seeing
people suffering and things like that. Really I’m here to see the beauty and
to the extent that I can help tourism grow, you know, |
08:25 |
Lisa 100% |
spending
my money in places like this I really am happy to do that and enjoy doing
that, but no I don’t want to see the unhappy side effects of war. And I know
that there are people who do that and that’s just... I don’t... that’s not
what I’m here for. |
08:39 |
Buddha site |
It’s
very sad, it’s very bleak and tourism is a way out, but if you can’t
guarantee the safety of tourists and most people |
08:53 |
Lisa 100% |
are
fearful of Afghanistan, and if you can’t absolutely say yes, you’re going to
be safe, and you know, we’re going to drive you around in a two decker bus or
something, you know, people aren’t going to come which is very sad because
they’re missing a lot”. |
09:00 |
Girl sitting on rock/Girl
walking |
Music
|
09:14 |
|
BENNETT:
Amid the uncertainty, an assertive generation of young women has no intention
|
09:21 |
Zakia leaves hotel on
bicycle |
of
returning to the conservative past. |
09:26 |
Zakia rides bicycle |
Music
|
09:36 |
|
BENNETT: 21 year old Zakia Dawood is university
educated and works as a hotel receptionist and she’s a member of
Afghanistan’s female cycling team. All of this is done with both parents’
enthusiastic blessing. |
09:42 |
|
Music
|
09:58 |
|
ZAKIA
DAWOOD: “My family’s open minded – many other Afghan families are narrow
minded people. They have some old fashioned thoughts – they don’t allow their
daughters to go outside – but our family doesn’t have such thoughts and there
is equality between men and women”. |
10:05 |
Zakia and Bennett at Zakia’s
home |
|
10:29 |
|
BENNETT:
Zakia’s family is comfortable by Bamiyan standards. Her father works as a
university driver. Brother Mahdi and sisters Reihana and Haniah attend
school. |
10:54 |
|
“Does
your father ever cook?” ZAKIA
DAWOOD: “Yes sometimes my father cooks... just eggs. Just simple and easy to
cook. When my father cooks, my brother also helps him… to cook dinner. BENNETT:
“So you’re not a very traditional Afghan family”. ZAKIA
DAWOOD: “Yeah, yeah.... no”. |
11:09 |
Mohammed |
BENNETT:
Though Zakia’s father, Mohammed, is not in the kitchen tonight. MOHAMMED
DAWOOD: “God willing, in future I hope that all my children will be able to
study and get higher education”. |
11:34 |
Bennett shares meal with
family |
BENNETT:
Like many Hazara, Mohammed fled to Shia Iran during the civil war of the
‘90s. There he married and started his family. They were encouraged to return
ten years ago with the promise of a better life in the new post-Taliban
Afghanistan. Now he fears that the very freedom Zakia enjoys, makes her a
target. |
11:50 |
|
MOHAMMED
DAWOOD: “Yes, I’m worried, because Pakistan is supporting them |
12:20 |
Mohammed |
and
some of our neighbouring countries. They don’t want us to have peace. If it
gets to that point, Bamiyan people must stand against the Taliban and fight
them. If they receive weapons and ammunition, they’ll defend Bamiyan well and
stop the Taliban entering”. |
12:26 |
Zakia and Bennett walk |
ZAKIA
DAWOOD: “It’s hard for me, but that doesn’t mean I should sit at home
thinking that the Taliban might get me… kill me. |
12:45 |
Zakia 100% |
I
always confront these problems and will continue to do so. If I stop
struggling against these difficulties, I will be subjugated”. |
12:56 |
Bamiyan people GVs |
|
13:07 |
Zakia enters women’s cafe |
BENNETT:
Zakia draws strength from like-minded Hazara women who defy pressure to
conform to traditional female roles. |
13:16 |
Zakia greet Najiba |
Najiba
Noori runs her own handcrafts business and aspires to be a photographer and
documentary maker. Fulfilling her dreams means leaving the safety of Bamiyan
and making regular road trips to the capital Kabul. But it’s a career path
fraught with great risks. NAJIBA
NOORI: “Yes, it is very dangerous. |
13:26 |
Najiba 100% |
Once
I was travelling from Kabul and I saw the Taliban with my own eyes. Two
Talibs checked out our car, but when they saw us all veiled they didn’t say
anything. |
13:56 |
Najiba’s photos on laptop |
As
a woman I’m scared to travel on the road. |
14:07 |
Najiba 100% |
There’s
a chance that the Taliban or some other group might attack. For me, as a
woman I have to protect myself against rape. I’m scared, but I have to be
brave and keep going to Kabul – like a man. I must be strong”. |
14:12 |
Checkpoint on road |
BENNETT:
Steely nerves are essential. Between here and Kabul is now Taliban territory.
While international tourists can afford the $200 for a safe flight to Kabul,
Hazaras are forced to run the gauntlet down what’s now dubbed the death road.
|
14:35 |
|
The
Taliban now compete with the newly arrived Islamic State for power amongst
jihadists, each faction seeking to demonstrate their brutality against the
Shia Hazara. Last November, in another province, seven Hazara travellers,
including a 7 year old girl, were pulled from the vehicle by suspected IS
militants and beheaded. |
15:03 |
Bennett to camera at
checkpoint |
“Well
this checkpoint is about half an hour from Bamiyan city and about another
half an hour down that way you’ll meet the first Taliban checkpoint. It’s an
hour or so if you’re coming in from the Wardak way. For the Hazaras who brave
extortion, kidnappings and even beheadings, making it here brings a sense of
great relief, |
15:31 |
Border guards conduct
searches |
but
for the border guards who search and patrol this area, it’s a difficult and
dangerous job. Not only do they have to keep potential insurgents out, they
also have to search for explosives that can be hidden in just about anything.
|
15:49 |
Bennett to camera at
checkpoint |
And
that’s perhaps the greatest threat here, is not an all-out assault over the
mountains, but an ever increasing campaign of intimidation through bombings”. |
16:02 |
Police
Commander Reza Moin at checkpoint |
Police
Commander Reza Moin and his men seized 350 km of bomb making material last
year. They search 500 vehicles which pass through here each day. One car bomb
and this gateway to Bamiyan could be breached. |
16:11 |
Command Reza 100% |
REZA
MOIN: “For the sake of Bamiyan we are prepared to sacrifice our lives so the
people can live in peace and security. |
16:33 |
|
The
police security command in Bamiyan is inadequate. We are short of police and
we’re requesting the government to send reinforcements so we can secure
Bamiyan and the major highways”. |
16:41 |
Scenic views |
Music
|
17:02 |
Bennett walks with Jawad |
BENNETT:
Hazara civil rights activist, Jawad Sady Lakoo, says this is a community
still traumatised by the recent past |
17:08 |
File footage. Taliban on
trucks. Super: |
First,
the Soviet invasion, civil war, then the Taliban takeover in 1990s. |
17:17 |
|
JAWAD
LAKOO: [civil rights activist] “I remember when the Taliban came, most of the
people were afraid because the rumour about the Taliban was that they will
kill all the kids of Hazaras – or the animals of Hazaras. |
17:29 |
Jawad 100%. Super: |
I
remember the burning of the cities, the bazaar and just... the lining up of
the people and killing them – massacres like this. |
17:43 |
File footage. Taliban |
I
remember that |
17:51 |
Jawad/Taliban |
three
of my uncles they just took them from their shops and lined them up with more
than 300 people. Once they shot... just killed them, just fired on them”. |
17:58 |
|
BENNETT:
The Taliban were swept away by the US led coalition in late 2001. |
18:12 |
File footage. New Zealand
peacekeeping force |
New
Zealand soldiers kept the peace in Bamiyan for a decade before leaving in
2013. Now the fighting edges ever closer to the valley. |
18:17 |
Bamiyan GVs |
Music/Call
to prayer |
18:29 |
|
BENNETT: Even by Afghanistan’s standards, Bamiyan
is desperately poor. Hazara complained that they never saw the billions of
dollars in aid poured into the country after the US led takeover. |
18:42 |
Buddhist monks’ caves |
A
few hundred metres from where the Buddhas once stood are caves which
centuries ago sheltered Buddhist monks. |
19:03 |
Jawad and Bennett walk at
caves |
JAWAD
LAKOO: [to Bennett] There are one thousand two hundred caves in Bamiyan. BENNETT:
Jawad says this is now home for hundreds of families driven off their lands
by years of conflict. |
19:10 |
Jawad and Bennett visit
Sakina living in cave |
JAWAD
LAKOO: “James, there are the families who’ve been living for more than a
decade here in the caves in Bamiyan, and mostly they’re coming and going.
When their situation gets better, they go on to the next place”. |
19:23 |
|
BENNETT:
18 year old Sakina Ghafar is mother to two small children. She’s struggling
to feed them and stay warm while her husband is off looking for work. |
19:43 |
|
SAKINA
GHAFAR: “We came here a year ago and have been living in this cave for three
months. |
19:54 |
Sakina |
We
don’t have anything, no land, no livestock – and decided to come here to
Bamiyan to find work. Last year was a little better – but this year,
nothing”. |
19:59 |
Sakina lights heater |
BENNETT:
Jawad says the absence of mains power or running water in a city of 350,000
shows wilful neglect by Kabul. |
20:13 |
Men on motorbike |
JAWAD
LAKOO: “We cannot deny the discrimination of the central government against
the Hazaras, against the Shia. They are thinking that the Bamiyan and |
20:28 |
Jawad |
the
Hazaras are not on the priority list of the government because they put all
their attention and all their resources into the southern and northern parts
of Afghanistan”. |
20:40 |
Destroyed Buddha statue site |
Music
|
20:52 |
|
BENNETT:
There is one more unresolved question – should the Buddhas be rebuilt from
these caged pieces of precious rubble? |
20:58 |
Time lapse |
Music
|
21:06 |
|
BENNETT: Last summer, a wealthy Chinese adventure
tourist provided |
21:12 |
Laser light show. Super: |
a
glimpse of the possible, bankrolling this light show. Advocates argue
rebuilding at least one is just as important for Afghanistan as the
resurrection of the New York’s ruined World Trade Center site was for
America. |
21:16 |
Buddha site |
JAWAD
LAKOO: “The rebuilding of Buddha niches is the dream of each and every one of
the Hazaras because we think the greatest |
21:40 |
Jawad |
proof
of our identity in our civilisation is the Buddha niches”. |
21:51 |
Buddha site |
BENNETT:
But that dream is tempered by fear. JAWAD
LAKOO: “One of the questions was that if we start the rebuilding of the
Buddha, |
21:56 |
Jawad |
the
Taliban will tread once again in Bamiyan. Do you have the power to save the
Buddha again or not? |
22:06 |
Buddha niche |
And
it is a threat. We do not want to start building now”. |
22:11 |
Return to ski challenge |
Music
|
22:16 |
Women’s ski race |
BENNETT:
Back on the slopes, it’s time for the local Hazara women’s race. |
22:25 |
Zakia takes part in ski race |
Zakia’s
not only a national cyclist, she’s also a skier and her parents are here to
support her. |
22:32 |
|
Music
|
22:40 |
|
BENNETT: Amidst the enthusiasm remains the question
of what and who lies beyond the horizon. |
22:55 |
Zakia 100% |
ZAKIA
DAWOOD: “If the international community leaves Afghanistan the Taliban will
be back in power for sure and peace will never return to Afghanistan. And
they’ll start killing this generation of Hazara people again, just as they
did before”. |
23:04 |
Women’s ski race |
Music
|
23:25 |
|
BENNETT:
Hundreds of thousands of Hazara have already fled abroad, seeking asylum
across the globe from Germany to Australia. |
23:34 |
Zakia/Ski race |
ZAKIA
DAWOOD: “Sometimes I think if the Taliban comes to Bamiyan or if fighting
starts again in Bamiyan, I ask myself, what can I do? Should I leave Bamiyan
and go to a foreign country?” |
23:43 |
|
Music
|
24:03 |
Najiba/Ski race |
NAJIBA
NOORI: “I think the Taliban is definitely coming to Bamiyan. And when that
day comes they’ll be much stronger. If they come to Bamiyan, this time
they’ll come well prepared. And this time they will destroy every single
thing in Bamiyan – even what’s left of the Buddhas”. |
24:08 |
|
Music |
24:37 |
|
LISA
FUERST: “If the Taliban came again, I don’t know that they would survive. |
24:45 |
Lisa/Ski race |
That’s
crushing. I mean they are warm people. They have so much to give and so much
to offer to the world. The culture here, to lose this is just a sin. It would
be shameful. Just beyond shameful. We shouldn’t allow that to happen”. Music |
24:48 25:00 |
|
|
|
Credits |
Reporter – James Bennett Camera/Director – Geoff Lye Editor – Garth Thomas Additional vision credit for Buddha
light show sequence: “On The Road Team - China”. Producer – Mark Corcoran Executive producer – Marianne Leitch abc.net.au/foreign © 2016 |
|
* map patch |
Accompanying
v/o: Located on the ancient
Silk Route, Bamiyan is the capital of Bamiyan province, and lies about 240
kilometres north west of Kabul. |
|