POST
PRODUCTION
SCRIPT
FOUR
CORNERS
2019
Tell
the World
45
mins 21 secs
©2019
ABC
Ultimo Centre
700
Harris Street Ultimo
NSW
2007 Australia
GPO
Box 9994
Sydney
NSW
2001 Australia
Phone:
: :61 2 8333 3314
e-mail : kimpton.scott@abc.net.au
Precis |
Tell
the world: Exposing how China is creating the world’s largest prison. |
|
|
“People
started to literally disappear, communities were being emptied of adult men
and women.” China researcher |
|
|
It’s
a remote corner of the world, but what is taking place there is nothing short
of breathtaking. |
|
|
“My
older brother, younger brothers and two younger sisters, five siblings were
all taken by… masked police. Heavily armed Special Forces police
raided their home and taken (sic) them by covering their face and shackling
them in front of the kids.” Australian Uyghur |
|
|
Xinjiang
province is a vast area of deserts and mountains where the ancient Silk Road
once ran. Today its Uyghur population is being systematically
rounded up with estimates of as many as a million citizens being held in
detention. |
|
|
“I
realised it was kind of next level material in terms of what the Chinese
state is capable of doing.” Open source investigator |
|
|
In
this investigation by reporter Sophie McNeill, Four Corners uncovers
disturbing evidence of how China is effectively operating the world’s largest
prison. |
|
|
“You
have to watch the brainwashing program on TV in the detention
centre. In that room they put (a) chain onto my ankle, put the
handcuffs on my hand.” Australian Uyghur detainee |
|
|
Even
those still left in their homes are being monitored. The
communist regime is using cutting edge technology, mass surveillance tools
and artificial intelligence to control an entire population. |
|
|
“Every
200 meters, there’s checkpoints. They check your IDs. They will check your
smartphone.” Australian Uyghur |
|
|
By
piecing together witness accounts from Australian citizens caught up in the
Chinese Government’s campaign, along with satellite imagery analysis and
official documents uncovered online, the truth about what is occurring in
Xinjiang is laid bare. |
|
|
“I
realised the magnitude and the impact… it was really something else.” Open
source investigator |
|
|
The
program has uncovered evidence of detainees being forced to work in factories
with implications for Australian companies doing business in the region. |
|
|
“Western
companies stand an increasing risk of having products made by forced or at
least highly involuntary labour.” Academic |
|
|
The
program will also reveal concerning evidence about Australia’s links to
China’s dystopian surveillance state and the tools used to racially profile
its own citizens. |
|
|
“Essentially
by doing that, we're being complicit in the human rights abuses that are
occurring in Xinjiang and in China more widely.” Surveillance
researcher |
|
|
The
events unfolding in China are creating heartbreak for Uyghurs in
Australia. They have stayed quiet for fear of provoking the
authorities into punishing their relatives. Now, in desperation they
are breaking their silence to tell the world what is going on. |
|
|
“She
said ‘If I am not released, cannot get out of here, please speak up for
me. Stand for me. Never give up’.” Uyghur Australian |
|
|
“Now
I have to speak out. I think Australians, all the Australia need to know this
story.” Uyghur Australian |
|
Episode
Teaser: |
Music |
00:10 |
|
SOPHIE MCNEILL, Reporter: Xinjiang
in China’s northwest. A UN panel says the region resembles a “massive
internment camp” – where more than one million Muslim minorities have been
rounded up, detained and forcibly indoctrinated by the Chinese regime. |
00:20 |
Turan |
ADAM
TURAN: All of us,
many of us will cry when we're alone. We decided to talk about it, just tell
the world, tell everyone what happened, what's been happen, what’s happening
now. |
00:48 |
|
SOPHIE MCNEILL, Reporter:
Australian citizens and permanent residents have been targeted and jailed
here. Others are still trapped under constant surveillance, their passports
seized. |
01:04 |
Abudusalamu |
SADAM ABUDUSALAMU: Every
single people overseas lost someone in their family, and I’m one of the
victims. |
01:17 |
Satellite images |
SOPHIE MCNEILL, Reporter:
Witness accounts, satellite imagery and Communist party documents reveal what
appears to be largest imprisonment of people on the basis of
religion since the Holocaust. |
01:27 |
Leibold |
ASSOC
PROF. JAMES LEIBOLD, Ethnic policy in China, La Trobe University: This is an act of cultural genocide and one
of the worst human rights abuses of our time. |
01:42 |
Zenz |
Dr Adrian Zenz,
Independent researcher: I'm quite used to uncovering dirty secrets
of the Chinese government, but when I realised the magnitude and the impact,
the implications of what I found, it was, it was really something else. |
01:47 |
McNeill to camera. Super: |
02:04 |
|
GFX Titles: |
Music |
02:25 |
Australian
Uyghur community members hold up photos of missing family members |
SOPHIE MCNEILL, reporter: All around Australia, members of the Uyghur
community are missing someone. |
02:38 |
|
Everyone has a family member detained,
incarcerated or trapped in Xinjiang. |
02:50 |
|
Many have stayed quiet, out of fear for their
relatives. But now, in desperation, they are coming forward to tell their
story. |
02:57 |
Majid 100%. Super: |
NURMUHAMMAD
MAJID, East Turkistan Australian Association: My older brother, younger brothers and two
younger sisters, five siblings were all taken by the Chinese government. |
03:08 |
|
Masked police, heavily armed Special Forces
police raided their home and taken them by covering their face and shackling
them in front of the kids. |
03:18 |
Turan 100%. Super: |
ADAM TURAN: They took my father and other
brother and they detained them to the internment camps. |
03:30 |
Abudusalamu 100%. Super: |
SADAM ABUDUSALAMU: As a
father, as a husband, most important thing is your wife and your kids and
they are not with me. |
03:39 |
|
Music
|
03:45 |
Abudusalamu on phone with children and wife |
|
04:01 |
|
SOPHIE
MCNEILL, Reporter: Sadam Abudusalamu left Xinjiang to study in Australia ten
years ago and became an Australian citizen in 2013. |
04:16 |
|
NADILA: So how are, you are you ok? SADAM
ABUDUSALAMU: Yeah, I’m good how about you? NADILA: I’m ok. |
04:27 |
|
Is there any news about our case? When will
you get us out? SADAM
ABUDUSALAMU: Soon, soon. Hopefully finalised soon. |
04:31 |
|
SOPHIE MCNEILL, Reporter: He has never met
his son Lutfy, who is almost two years old. The toddler is trapped in
Xinjiang with Sadam’s wife Nadila. |
04:40 |
|
SADAM ABUDUSALAMU Please
don’t cry darling. Don’t cry bubba. NADILA: Can you please find a way to get us
out of here soon? |
04:51 |
|
SADAM ABUDUSALAMU: All
right well, I love you. NADILA: I love you. |
05:03 |
Abudusalamu 100% |
SADAM ABUDUSALAMU: All
I want is live a normal life like Australian. Stay with my son, stay with my
wife. That’s all I want. What
does it be so hard to bring my wife and my son here? |
05:16 |
Ingle Farm Recreation Centre. Uyghurs
community function |
|
05:29 |
|
SOPHIE
MCNEILL, Reporter: There are several thousand Uyghurs in Australia, Turkic
speaking Muslims, many came to this country seeking asylum from communist
party persecution. |
05:39 |
|
Free
to practice their religion here, in Xinjiang the Chinese government has
effectively outlawed Islam. |
05:59 |
Abudusalamu 100% |
SADAM ABUDUSALAMU: Can't pray. Can't fast,
need to speak Chinese in the school. |
06:11 |
Sawut 100%. Suer: |
NURGUL SAWUT, Australian Uyghur Association:
The government come to that ridiculous point where actually they're
controlling the way we look. Men not
allowed to have a beard, and a female not allowed to have scarf, even long
dress. |
06:15 |
Police with Uyghur men on street |
Music |
06:28 |
|
SOPHIE
MCNEILL, Reporter: The crackdown on
Uyghurs followed decades of religious and separatist tensions…and after
millions of Han Chinese were resettled in the region. |
06:34 |
Byler 100%. Super: |
DR. DARREN
BYLER, anthropologist, University of Washington: Uyghurs began to feel
themselves being dispossessed of their land, dispossessed of their way of
life. |
06:48 |
Protests |
SOPHIE
MCNEILL, Reporter: In July 2009,
demonstrations broke out. |
06:54 |
|
Nearly 200 people were
killed, with reports that over 1000 Uyghurs were arrested. |
07:07 |
Troops in carriers |
In response, Beijing
rolled out what it called the ‘strike hard campaign’ in Uyghur areas. |
07:18 |
Leibold 100%. Super: |
ASSOC
PROF. JAMES LEIBOLD, Ethnic policy in China, La Trobe University: What it began to do is really systematically
step up its police presence as well as its party infrastructure in Xinjiang, to
begin to surveil the Uyghur population. |
07:32 |
|
And so, some of them struck back in really
horrific ways. |
07:46 |
[Archival] Tiananmen car bombing |
There is a suicide car bombing in Tiananmen,
in Beijing. |
07:49 |
[Archival] Kunming station attack |
There was this attack on a train station in
Kunming that left over 20 innocent train travellers massacred quite brutally. |
07-55 |
Byler 100% |
DR. DARREN BYLER,
anthropologist, University of Washington: That's really when the rhetoric of
terrorism really took off as, something you could use to label Uyghurs as a
group, that they're all potentially terrorists and so, you know, using any
means necessary is justified. |
08:07 |
Driving shots. Xinjiang |
Music |
08:20 |
Xinjiang GVs/Surveillance cameras/Police presence |
|
08:29 |
Photos. Sadam and Nadila |
SOPHIE MCNEILL, Reporter:
In 2016, Sadam went back to Xinjiang to marry his girlfriend Nadila. |
08:45 |
|
After their honeymoon to
America and Turkey Nadila became pregnant. |
08:58 |
|
SADAM ABUDUSALAMU: We get
the positive test. |
09-05 |
Abudusalamu 100%. Super: |
She's pregnant. That's
another best happiness moment for me. I'm nervous, actually. Like, I'm going to be dad,
I'm going to have son. I'm going to have baby. I was nervous and happy. |
09:08 |
Photos. Nadila pregnant |
SOPHIE MCNEILL, Reporter: Sadam came back
to Australia in early 2017 for work, while Nadila waited in Xinjiang for her
spouse visa to be approved. |
09:22 |
Xinjiang. Soldiers. Mao statue in b/g |
When
Beijing
suddenly launched its brutal new campaign. |
09:32 |
Abudusalamu 100% |
SADAM ABUDUSALAMU:
Suddenly, she called me: "Our government starts taking people's
passport.” |
09:40 |
Xinjiang security checkpoint./Stills. Police
interrogate Uyghurs |
SOPHIE MCNEILL, Reporter:
Xinjiang essentially became the world’s largest open-air prison, with tight
travel restrictions placed on Uyghurs and other Muslim minorities. |
09:44 |
|
Eleven million Uyghurs were
now a target. |
10:00 |
Driving shots. Walled camps in distance |
The first reports of
citizens being rounded up and detained in camps started trickling through. |
10:06 |
Stills. Camp exteriors |
NURMUHAMMAD MAJID, East Turkistan Australian
Association: In the
community, we heard stories of people's direct messages of their family
members were taken. |
10:13 |
Majid 100%. Super: |
Everyone was
panicking, everyone was trying to find out whether their family members were
safe or not. |
10:22 |
Still. Razor wire around camp |
ADAM
TURAN: We start to hear everyone's family being detained. |
10:28 |
Turan 100%. Super: |
Like
ordinary people, average people, their family members being detained and then
I realised something is going on. |
10:33 |
Mao statue. Xinjiang |
SOPHIE MCNEILL, Reporter:
Uyghurs who had visited Muslim countries or had lived overseas were among the
first targeted. |
10:39 |
Abudusalamu 100% |
SADAM ABUDUSALAMU: Whoever
went to the Turkey, Saudi Arabia or any Muslim country, they're putting in
the people to the jail or concentration camp. |
10:49 |
Empty buildings |
ASSOC PROF. JAMES LEIBOLD, Ethnic
policy in China, La Trobe University: People started literally disappearing. |
10:57 |
|
Communities were being
emptied of adult men and women. |
11:01 |
Newborn Lutfy. Sadam's son |
SOPHIE
MCNEILL, Reporter: Sadam was prevented from being with Nadila when she gave
birth – the Chinese consulate in Sydney refused to give him a visa. |
11:12 |
Abudusalamu 100% |
SADAM ABUDUSALAMU I wasn't
there when he born. |
11:22 |
|
I
imagine how hard for Nadila to having a baby by herself. I wasn't staying next to
her. So, it was so hard. |
11:29 |
Abudusalamu on train |
Music |
11:39 |
|
SOPHIE MCNEILL, Reporter:
Not long after Lutfy was born, Sadam received terrible news. Security forces
had arrived at Nadila’s family home. |
11:43 |
|
SADAM ABUDUSALAMU: I was on the train to the work.
Then I get the message from my wife's friends saying, "Oh, your wife's
been taken." I just quietly crying in the train.
Even the people in train asking me, "What's happening? What's
happening?" And I can’t tell them. |
11:54 |
Abudusalamu 100% |
The Chinese government took her and I don't
know where. |
12:12 |
Phone video. Nadila with Lutfy |
Nadila:
" Dada, I love you… SOPHIE
MCNEILL, Reporter: After two weeks, Sadam heard his wife had been released
but Nadila remains trapped in Xinjiang with baby Lutfy – forbidden from
travelling and living in fear of rearrest. |
12:16 |
|
SADAM ABUDUSALAMU: She's
scared. She's always hoping, "please, let me out from here.” |
12:38 |
Abudusalamu 100% |
He's getting older and
older. Every day passing, he doesn't know his dad. |
12:43 |
Almas driving |
Music |
12:52 |
|
SOPHIE
MCNEILL, Reporter: In Adelaide, Sadam’s friend Almas, also received
terrifying news from home. His
wife Zainab had been taken. |
12:56 |
Nizamidin 100%. Super: |
ALMAS Nizamidin: My
wife been arrested by Chinese police. They dress in undercover, I think,
there's more than eight or nine police officers. |
13:08 |
Still. Zainab |
SOPHIE MCNEILL, Reporter:
Zainab’s family witnessed security forces put a black hood over her head and
bundle her into a van. She
was seven weeks pregnant. |
13:18 |
|
ALMAS Nizamidin: I
can't leave her like that, so I booked a flight ticket. Very next day, I left
to Urumqi. So, I spent three months' time in Urumqi, |
13:28 |
|
and then I only can get the information she has
been arrested because of the reason she did study in Egypt. |
13:44 |
Xinjiang
camps |
SOPHIE
MCNEILL, Reporter: Almas spent weeks in Xinjiang searching for his wife,
before being summoned by the police. |
13:51 |
Nizamidin 100% |
ALMAS Nizamidin: They
ask me to come to police station, talk to me face to face. And then when I
went there, they gave me the piece of paper, say, I need to get out the
country in 24 hours. |
14:03 |
Still. Almas's mother |
SOPHIE
MCNEILL, Reporter: After
Almas flew back to Australia, the Chinese security forces came for his
fifty-year-old mother. |
14:16 |
Nizamidin 100% |
ALMAS Nizamidin She's a high school maths teacher. She's
been work for Chinese government for thirty years. |
14:27 |
Still. Almas's mother |
They take her from the
house. |
14:33 |
Nizamidin 100% |
The police officer come to
the house and then knock the door and then arrest her. |
14:36 |
Nizamidin sitting in car. Night. |
SOPHIE
MCNEILL, Reporter: In April, Almas received an email from an official from
the Department of Foreign Affairs in Canberra. |
14:46 |
|
She informed him that the
Chinese government had sentenced his wife to seven years in jail for the
crime of “assembling a crowd to
disturb social order.” |
14:52 |
Still. Zainab
and Almas |
ALMAS Nizamidin: And
then they say that my wife was assembling a crowd. She can't even go shopping
by herself. Like she’s very scared. |
15:07 |
Nizamidin 100% |
They arrest her like she did like assembling
a crowd to disturb social order. That's impossible. |
15:17 |
Almas holds up photo of wife and mother |
They kill my heart. My wife, my mom, they're like so important
for me. |
15:25 |
Nizamidin 100% |
it's my responsibility to
protect them, but I couldn't protect them. |
15:34 |
Satellite photos of camps |
Music
|
15:41 |
|
SOPHIE
MCNEILL, Reporter: At first, China
tried to deny these camps existed. But using satellite imagery, a team of
researchers and scholars across the globe have uncovered the evidence. |
15:45 |
|
NATHAN RUSER, Satellite analyst,
Australian Strategic Policy Institute: Essentially, you're looking for a large,
highly securitised facility |
16:00 |
Ruser 100%. Super: |
where almost every aspect of the movement
inside these areas is completely restrained.
|
16:03 |
Satellite photos of camps |
You're looking for walls surrounding the
whole facility with watchtowers on the edges of it and specifically you're
looking for internal fencing, barbed wire, three-metre high fencing. |
16:09 |
GFX Map. Xinjiang showing camps |
SOPHIE
MCNEILL, Reporter: The scale of the mass internment program is
chilling. Researchers have now identified and mapped nearly 100 suspected
re-education camps and detention facilities across Xinjiang. |
16:19 |
Zenz 100%. Super: |
DR ADRIAN ZENZ Independent
researcher: It's basically
clear that a huge percentage of the middle age range especially Uyghurs aged
between 18 and 45 years, a very large percentage of them are in some form of
internment or prison. |
16:38 |
Zenz at computer |
SOPHIE MCNEILL, Reporter:
Using regime documents that academics tracked down online, the full detail of
what China is doing to its Muslim citizens is being revealed. |
16:52 |
Zenz 100% |
DR ADRIAN ZENZ Independent researcher: For
example budget reports, government
reports, work reports. Then also procurement bids, construction
bids that were also very detailed that said, "We need a re-education
camp built in this area and it needs to be this big and it needs to have
surrounding walls, barbed wire, towers, surveillance equipment, cameras"
and so on and so forth. |
17:09 |
Byler 100%. Super: |
DR DARREN BYLER, Anthropologist, University
of Washington: They were buying police batons, tasers, different instruments
that could be used in torture, like cattle prods, stun guns, pepper spray,
all these sort of things that you would find in a prison setting. |
17:31 |
'Bitter Winter' excerpt |
SOPHIE
MCNEILL, Reporter: This footage filmed secretly by human rights activists
shows the inside of these camps, cells fitted with double iron doors, keypad
locks and cameras, walls covered with slogans praising Chinese President Xi
Jinping and in the “classrooms” teachers separated from “students” by
railings and wire. |
17:48 |
Propaganda videos |
These slick propaganda videos claim Uyghurs are
happy with their re-education. |
18:24 |
|
VIDEO
[SUBTITLES]: If we were not saved before it was too late from being fooled I
would have betrayed this great country. |
18:36 |
|
VIDEO
[SUBTITLES]: I learned more about the
law and I realised I was wrong. SOPHIE
MCNEILL, Reporter: The
Chinese government |
18:46 |
Propaganda poster |
describes its new campaign as “breaking the
roots” of extremists. |
18:53 |
Byler 100% |
DR. DARREN BYLER, Anthropologist,
University of Washington: And so what they're doing when they say they want
to break the roots, break the lineage is they want to eliminate the basic
institutions, the basic elements of Uyghur culture, Uyghur society. |
19:00 |
Still. Incarcerated men. Super: |
They're trying to transform
the entire society. |
19:11 |
Stills. Hayrullah
Mai |
SOPHIE
MCNEILL, Reporter: Thirty-seven-year-old
Melbourne plasterer Hayrullah Mai is one of three Australian citizens who
have been jailed in Xinjiang. He’s speaking out for the first time. |
19:22 |
Mai 100%. Super: |
HAYRULLAH
MAI: It's a bit
hard to explain in my feeling at that time. Yeah, never been happen like that
before in my life. |
19:35 |
Sichuan Airlines planes, Chengdu airport |
SOPHIE
MCNEILL, Reporter: In August 2017, while travelling on his Australian
passport, Hayrullah was questioned and then detained at China’s Chengdu
airport. |
19:45 |
Mai 100% |
HAYRULLAH
MAI: When I go to
that detention centre in Chengdu, they put chain onto my ankle, put on the
handcuffs on my hand. So, I just a bit
shocked because I don't know what's the reason why they should to do this to
me. |
19:59 |
Close on hands being cuffed |
SOPHIE
MCNEILL, Reporter: Hayrullah
wasn’t allowed to call the Australian embassy or his family. |
20:21 |
Planes, Chengdu airport |
Security
forces marched him onto a plane and flew him to Xinjiang. He says he was brought here |
20:29 |
Satellite photo, detention centre. Super: Google,
DigitalGlobe |
to
this detention centre near Urumqi and put in a cell with around forty other
men. |
20:36 |
Mai 100% |
HAYRULLAH MAI: Yeah, there is not enough space for you just to lie down
properly and then turn around, something like that. You can’t do that. |
20:46 |
|
We just sleeping two hours.
After two hours, we wake up. And then we standing two hours, and then they
wake up, you going to sleep, something like that. |
20:54 |
Super: Reconstruction |
SOPHIE MCNEILL, Reporter:
Classified as a “potential terrorist”, each day the Australian citizen was
forced to undergo six hours of indoctrination praising the Chinese communist
party and president Xi Jinping. |
21:03 |
|
HAYRULLAH MAI: You have to
watch the brainwashing program on TV. |
21:18 |
Mai 100% |
There is TV in the detention centre in that
room. That TV the people is talking about the communist party's rules and
then that Xi Jinping is good, something like that. |
21:26 |
Super: Reconstruction. Official visits Mai |
Music |
21:42 |
|
SOPHIE
MCNEILL, Reporter: After
two weeks Hayrullah says he received a visit from an Australian official who
introduced himself as “Mark” from the Beijing Embassy. HAYRULLAH
MAI: He trying to
ask the officials, |
21:45 |
Mai 100% |
Chinese officials, this guy asking me
"why you guys put him to the detention centre and then lock him up about
two weeks, more than two weeks, what's the reason?" And then the Chinese
official says, "Still not time to answer to this question." |
21:58 |
Stills. Mai, wife and stepson |
SOPHIE
MCNEILL, Reporter: A week later Hayrullah was released to be with his wife
and his stepson. But authorities ordered him to leave Xinjiang and banned him
from visiting for five years. Hayrullah’s wife was blocked from leaving with
him. HAYRULLAH MAI: She just
kept saying, |
22:18 |
Mai 100% |
"Don't leave me alone.
Don't leave me alone. Take me with you. I can't live without you." That feeling is, you know, break my heart.
I just left. Even I can't turn around and see her again because I from far
away near the gate, I can see her just crying, crying. |
22:43 |
Mai holds up photo of himself, wife and stepson |
Music |
23:22 |
Australian
Uyghur community members hold up photos of missing family members |
|
23:29 |
|
NURGUL SAWUT, Australian
Uyghur Association: We are going through survivor's guilt here, and because
we're living in a free country, and are safe and sound, yet we're living in
this emotional prison. We are walking, but walking dead almost. That's how I
can describe from our community's experience. |
23:42 |
Sawut 100%. Super: |
We feel ashamed. We feel
guilt, and because we can't do anything about to help them. We're doing what
we can, but this is not good enough help to help them. |
24:00 |
Turan
hold up photos of father |
SOPHIE MCNEILL, Reporter:
Adam Turan’s eighty-year-old father was among those rounded up and put in the
camps. |
24:12 |
Still. Turan with father |
ADAM
TURAN: He's
been loyal to the Chinese government all his life. He just average ordinary Turkic speaking
Uyghurs. |
24:21 |
Turan 100%. Super: |
He never done anything against government. |
24:33 |
Still. Turan's father |
SOPHIE
MCNEILL, Reporter: Adam’s dad was detained for nearly a year. He was finally
released last August but died only weeks later. |
24:36 |
Turan 100% |
ADAM TURAN: I couldn't call
my mum or any of my family members and I don't even know if my dad had a
funeral after his death. |
24:49 |
Still. Turan with mother and father |
SOPHIE MCNEILL, Reporter:
The last time Adam’s mum answered the phone she was at a police station –
held for receiving calls from overseas. ADAM TURAN: I used to call
my mum like a few days every week. |
25:02 |
Turan 100% |
She said, "Don't call me again, because
I can't pick up your phone anyway." So that was my last talk with my
mum. And I miss that every week. I try not to talk about it at home, but at
breakfast table, my kids ask sometimes like, "Do you have parents?"
It's hard to explain them what's going on. |
25:17 |
Turan holds up photo of father |
Music
|
26:15 |
Xinjiang Surveillance shots |
|
26:22 |
|
SOPHIE
MCNEILL, Reporter: Even those not detained in camps are subjected to an
extraordinary program of control. |
26:35 |
|
Xinjiang
has essentially become a huge lab to trial the latest surveillance
technology, using artificial intelligence. |
26:44 |
Nizamidin 100%. Super: |
ALMAS Nizamidin: Every
two hundred metres, there is checkpoints. They check your ID's. They will
check your smartphone. |
26:56 |
Young men's phones being checked by police |
SADAM ABUDUSALAMU: They just put your phone and then they
scan everything and if there's WhatsApp, Facebook, Twitter, anything |
27:02 |
Abudusalamu. Super: |
religious scholar, speech, praying app, that
kind of apps in your phone, you're in trouble. |
27:11 |
Xinjiang security checkpoint |
|
27:18 |
|
SOPHIE
MCNEILL, Reporter: Every Uyghur over 12 years old is forced to surrender
their biometric data including voice, blood, DNA samples and iris scans. |
27:20 |
Byler 100%. Super: |
DR. DARREN BYLER, Anthropologist,
University of Washington: So they had to speak into a device in order to get
a unique voice signature for each person and then they did a 3D face scan,
which meant that you had to have your face scanned from all directions,
making different expressions on your face, so that they would get a clear
reading of all of your emotions. |
27:35 |
Corporate video. Facial recognition technology |
SOPHIE MCNEILL, Reporter:
This corporate video shows off the latest advanced facial recognition
technology being used in Chinese cities. The communist party is now
using this to track Uyghurs – not just in Xinjiang but across the country. |
27:50 |
Byler 100% |
DR. DARREN BYLER, Anthropologist, University
of Washington: That's something that they're quite proud
of that they can detect, racial
difference or ethnic difference simply, you know, based on that appearance. |
28:10 |
GFX. Facial recognition |
SOPHIE MCNEILL, Reporter:
Four Corners can reveal that a researcher at an Australian university has
been involved in developing methods to better identify ethnic minorities in
China using AI. Curtin University Associate Professor |
28:18 |
Still Wangquan |
Liu Wanquan has been working on Chinese
government funded research that examines the faces of Uyghurs and how their
features could be better picked up in facial scanning. |
28:35 |
Leibold 100%. Super: |
ASSOC PROF. JAMES LEIBOLD, Ethnic
policy in China, La Trobe University: It's racial profiling, that's
essentially what this technology is being used for, to distinguish Uyghur
from Han. |
28:48 |
Super: Statement from Curtin University. On screen
text: |
SOPHIE MCNEILL, Reporter:
The university says the associate professor was solely focused on the provision of “technical advice to the
Chinese research team” and that Curtin |
28:53 |
On screen text: 'unequivocally
condemns the use of AI for any form of ethnic profiling to negatively impact and/or
persecute any person or group.' |
“unequivocally condemns
the use of AI for any form of ethnic profiling” that would “negatively impact and/or persecute
any person or group." |
29:06 |
On screen text: |
However, Curtin has told
Four Corners it is now reviewing its research approval procedures. ASSOC PROF. JAMES LEIBOLD,
Ethnic policy in China, La Trobe University: They will say, “Well, this is my
area of expertise. |
29:17 |
Leibold 100% |
Wow, I can use this stuff to identify a
Uyghur as opposed to a Han. What the Party State does with it is not my
responsibility.” Well, I think that's shameful and shocking. |
29:28 |
|
I
don't think Australian researchers should be involved in that, and it
violates human ethics, without a doubt. |
29:39 |
GFX. Data collection app. |
SOPHIE
MCNEILL, Reporter: The Chinese police
also use an app to track the purchases, phone data and travel routines of
Uyghurs. |
29:46 |
Police look at citizens' phones |
Human Rights Watch revealed that the app was
developed by CETC, a Chinese state-owned military tech company. |
29:56 |
McNeill to camera |
SOPHIE MCNEILL, REPORTER: In 2017, the University
of Technology in Sydney signed a 10 million dollar deal with CETC to
establish a research centre, that included projects on AI and surveillance. Four
Corners can reveal that the university is now conducting an internal review
into their partnership with the company. |
30:10 |
Leibold 100% |
ASSOC PROF. JAMES LEIBOLD, Ethnic
policy in China, La Trobe University: I think the UTS and other universities
here in Australia that have connections with any Party State company,
particularly in the military or security sector, needs to end those
contracts, and to pull out of those collaborative arrangements. I mean, essentially by doing that, we're being complicit
in the human rights abuses that are occurring in Xinjiang and in China more
widely. |
30:33 |
Uyghur building demolition |
Music |
30:59 |
|
SOPHIE
MCNEILL, Reporter: Uyghur culture is
being systematically erased. |
31:07 |
Satellite pictures. Destruction of mosques in Xinjiang. Super: |
Using satellite imagery, it is possible to track the destruction of
mosques in Xinjiang. Four Corners can confirm that this large mosque in Hotan
was demolished just weeks ago. |
31:16 |
|
Large areas of
traditional Uyghur housing have also been wiped out. |
31:40 |
Uyghur homes |
NATHAN RUSER, Satellite
analyst, Australian Strategic Policy Institute: You're seeing that being
systematically demolished |
31:50 |
Ruser 100% |
and, in its place, is
becoming high rise apartment buildings, which are a lot easy to control. |
31:54 |
Uyghur camps. Children behind fence |
SOPHIE MCNEILL, Reporter: There are grave fears for the children of
the one million Uyghurs believed to be held in camps. |
32:01 |
Video. Uyghur children singing |
NURGUL SAWUT, Australian
Uyghur Association: Those videos started leaked out, and we start seeing the
orphanage, |
32:13 |
Sawut 100%. Super: |
and the people even
identifying that some of their nieces and nephews actually inside of that
orphanage. |
32:22 |
Video. Uyghur children in kindergarten |
SOPHIE MCNEILL, Reporter: Official government documents reveal a
mass increase in the building and upgrading of kindergartens and boarding
schools in Xinjiang. Analysts say children are being deliberately
separated from their families. |
32:28 |
Byler 100%. Super: |
DR. DARREN BYLER, Anthropologist,
University of Washington: What's happening to the children is that, if both
parents are taken to the camps, often the children are removed from the
community that they're a part of and they're placed in boarding schools or
orphanages. |
32:50 |
Still. Kindergarten |
There's certainly been a
massive increase in the building of nurseries and other education facilities
for children. |
33:03 |
Byler 100% |
All Uyghur children are now
in the process of re-education or, you know, Chinese assimilation. |
33:09 |
|
Dr
Adrian Zenz,
Independent researcher: That's
also how you inhibit what's called intergenerational transmission of culture
and religion. |
33:15 |
Zenz 100%. Super: |
Meaning the parent's
ability to pass on the cultural and the spiritual heritage to the next
generation. If you can control that,
then you basically have control over the entire next generation of these
ethnic groups. |
33:25 |
Abudusalamu 100%. Super: |
SADAM ABUDUSALAMU: Why
you're doing this to the babies? That's the thing scares me all the time.
What's going to happen if I can't see my son again? That's the thing scare my
wife as well. |
33:41 |
Uyghur detainees working in
clothing factory |
SOPHIE
MCNEILL, Reporter: Meanwhile, inside
the camps, parents are being put to work. Mounting evidence suggests a system
of forced labour is emerging in Xinjiang. Last October, Chinese state
television broadcast these detainees dutifully sewing at a camp in Hotan. Dr Adrian Zenz,
Independent researcher: I'm quite used to uncovering |
33:58 |
Zenz 100% |
dirty
secrets of the Chinese government, but when I realised the magnitude and the impact,
the implications of what I found, it was, it was really something else. |
34:26 |
Zenz working on laptop, watching videos |
SOPHIE MCNEILL, Reporter:
Adrian Zenz has been combing through official government documents and state
media reports – and he’s found shocking new details of what’s happening
behind camp walls. |
4:38 |
|
Dr
Adrian Zenz,
Independent researcher: Basically,
there's a huge scheme going on, a huge plan in Xinjiang to put all kinds of
people into different forms of involuntary labour. |
34:54 |
|
They're being moved around
a bit like figures on a chess board, you know, and they're put into places
where the government can control them. |
35:03 |
|
This kind of cooperation is
not voluntary, it's being enforced. |
35:11 |
Uyghur detainees working in
clothing factory |
SOPHIE
MCNEILL, Reporter: Government propaganda reveals aspects of the new scheme. Here,
a young Uyghur woman espouses the positives of her “new job.” |
35:15 |
|
VIDEO [SUBTITLES]: We had the chance to
work in a garment factory. We learned how to operate the machines on our own. |
35:27 |
|
SOPHIE
MCNEILL, Reporter: Documents show how
detainee labour is being used to attract companies to set up shop in
Xinjiang. |
35:37 |
Zenz 100% |
Dr Adrian Zenz,
Independent researcher: For example, if a factory trains and then
employs a camp detainee, they get 5,000 renminbi per worker over a course of
three years. They also get intensive subsidies, for example they can use a
factory building for free for the first two years. |
35:46 |
|
The
most sort of shocking or problematic aspect of this whole scheme in Xinjiang
is that it's planned in such detail and enforced with such urgency. |
36:05 |
Uyghur detainees working in
clothing factory. Super: |
VIDEO [SUBTITLES]: I have rid myself of all extremist thought
and reinvent myself. Dr Adrian Zenz, Independent researcher: Those who are in the camps |
36:18 |
Zenz 100% |
are
supposed to get jobs, permanent factory jobs.
The reason is that in these jobs the government can control
them. They can't
just take off, they're all together. It's very easy to control people in
these environments, they also can't take off on Friday to go to the mosque,
they also can't fast, they cannot do basic religious practise. |
36:29 |
Gulnur Idreis holds up photo of detained sister |
SOPHIE
MCNEILL, Reporter: The sister of
Melbourne resident Gulnur Idreis is forced to work in one of these factories.
|
36:48 |
Still. Dilnur with child |
Dilnur is a qualified nurse and mother of two
children. |
37:01 |
Still. Dilnur and family |
In 2017 she and her husband were both arrested and
sent to the camps. |
37:07 |
Gulnur 100%. Super: |
She didn't know how to make
the clothes. |
37:15 |
Dilnur ID badge |
SOPHIE
MCNEILL, Reporter: In May this year Dilnur was transferred from the camp to
work for a textile manufacturer. Using
her employee ID card, |
37:22 |
Satellite pictures. Technology park, Urumqi Super: |
we traced the company here to this technology
park, 30 kilometres north of Urumqi. |
37:31 |
Still. Dilnur's children |
Dilnur told her sister she is only allowed home to
see her children and parents once a week. Her husband is still missing. GULNUR IDREIS: Is her husband still live or die, |
37:40 |
Gulnur 100% |
we don't know. What happened? If a bad thing
happened, I don't know anything. |
37:55 |
Gulnur with phone/GFX Notes on phone |
SOPHIE MCNEILL, Reporter: In June, after several months of no news,
Gulnur received a disturbing video call. |
38:01 |
|
It was Dilnur. Terrified of being monitored, she
scribbled out a series of notes begging her sister in
Melbourne to take the dangerous step of speaking out. |
38:11 |
Gulnur |
GULNUR IDREIS
[SUBTITLES]: If I am not released, cannot get out of here, please speak up
for me. Stand for me. Never give up. She wrote this down and showed it to me
and I saw it. |
38:26 |
GFX Notes on phone |
SOPHIE
MCNEILL, Reporter: The notes described what she wanted Gulnur to tell the
world. |
38:40 |
On screen text: |
"660
people are brought in shackled and handcuffed and it's big. They have no
choice, if they say something, they will end up in jail." |
38:49 |
Gulnur 100% |
GULNUR IDREIS [SUBTITLES] They are using innocent people. They are not giving them
any money and also their food is bad. They are torturing them in every way. |
39:00 |
GFX Notes on phone |
SOPHIE
MCNEILL, Reporter: Gulnur says her sister kept motioning that she wanted to
end her life. GULNUR IDREIS
[SUBTITLES] She looked very exhausted and emotionally very distressed. |
39:14 |
Gulnur 100% |
I
don’t know if what I say will come to anything. |
39:32 |
GFX: Corporate logos over map |
SOPHIE
MCNEILL, Reporter: Four Corners can
reveal that these brands sold in Australia use cotton from Xinjiang. |
39:39 |
|
Cotton On and Target Australia are now
investigating their relationships with suppliers and factories there. |
39:51 |
|
Cotton On even visited the region last September |
39:58 |
Satellite pictures. Factories/Re-education camp. Super: |
where their staff member met with a supplier. The
factory is just six kilometres from a massive re-education camp. Dr Adrian Zenz,
Independent researcher: Western companies |
40:05 |
Zenz 100%. Super: |
stand
an increasing risk of having products made by forced or at least highly
involuntary labour somewhere in the supply chains. It’s going to become
inevitable as the scheme is unfolding and getting bigger and bigger. |
40:17 |
GVs Sadam, apartment. |
Music
|
40:32 |
Sadam on apartment balcony |
SOPHIE
MCNEILL, Reporter: It has now been more than two years since Sadam has seen
his wife Nadila. Lutfy will turn two in August and Sadam is desperate for him
to be here for his birthday. |
40:41 |
Sadam 100%. Super: |
SADAM ABUDUSALAMU: I'm
totally broke actually, like financially, mentally physically. I used to be strong, big guy but this thing
just totally ruined my life. |
40:55 |
Passport office |
|
41:06 |
Sadam holding passport. With Bradley |
MICHAEL
BRADLEY, Sadam’s lawyer: Look at that, so cute. He looks like both of you,
you know. SADAM
ABUDUSALAMU: Hah, he looks like me. MICHAEL
BRADLEY, Sadam’s lawyer: You reckon? Yeah he does. SOPHIE MCNEILL, Reporter: After eight months of trying to secure
Australian citizenship for his baby, Sadam and his lawyer are finally picking
up Lutfy’s passport. |
41:11 |
|
SADAM
ABUDUSALAMU:
Finally, he is an Australian citizen with Australian passport. |
41:32 |
|
MICHAEL
BRADLEY, Sadam’s lawyer: It’s a big step. |
41:38 |
|
SOPHIE
MCNEILL, Reporter: Sadam hopes that he will be able to use it soon…and that
Nadila can come, too. |
41:41 |
|
SADAM
ABUDUSALAMU:
I just want to hold him. MICHAEL
BRADLEY, Sadam’s lawyer: I know. You are doing everything you can to get to
that. |
41:47 |
Chinese ambassador at Parliament House |
SOPHIE
MCNEILL, Reporter: The Chinese
ambassador made a rare public appearance three weeks ago at the Australia
China Business Council networking day at Parliament House. |
42:01 |
Ambassador addresses Australia China Business Council networking day.
Super: |
Cheng Jingye, China's Ambassador to
Australia: There are many reasons that underlie China’s
magnificent achievements; the most fundamental one is the unswerving adherence to the leadership of the Chinese
Communist Party. |
42:15 |
McNeill walks with ambassador |
SOPHIE
MCNEILL, Reporter: We tried to get
answers from the Ambassador about what they’re doing to the Uyghurs. |
42:28 |
|
SOPHIE
MCNEILL, Reporter: Why is the communist party doing this? Cheng Jingye, China's Ambassador to
Australia: No,
it’s training and education centre to help people who are affected by radical
ideas, ideology to better integrate. |
42:35 |
|
SOPHIE
MCNEILL, Reporter: What’s wrong with
them, why do they need reintegration? |
42:50 |
|
Cheng Jingye, China's Ambassador to
Australia: This
is to find the jobs and to make a better living. SOPHIE
MCNEILL, Reporter: They have jobs. Is it just because they are Muslim? Cheng Jingye, China's Ambassador to
Australia: No,
no, no. |
42:53 |
Ambassador departs |
DR ADRIAN ZENZ Independent
researcher: The end game, in my opinion, is very clearly the long-term
survival and rule of the communist party. |
43:07 |
Zenz 100% |
This is being achieved by
achieving complete ideological control over every part of China. |
43:16 |
Uyghurs
community members hold up photos |
Beijing has declared the
ultimate war on the religion and culture of these Turkic minorities in
Xinjiang, and it's not going to rest until they will be lastingly changed
forever. |
43:22 |
|
Music |
43:37 |
Adam Turan holds up photo of father |
ADAM TURAN: I think that's why they're doing it, to systematically
assimilate us into Chinese society. |
43:45 |
Turan 100% |
I think they want us to eat
like Chinese, walk like Chinese or live like Chinese or die like Chinese. |
43:52 |
Uyghurs
community members hold up photos |
ASSOC PROF. JAMES LEIBOLD, Ethnic
policy in China, La Trobe University: If you look at the legal definition of
genocide, it has to be systematic, it has to be intentional. |
43:59 |
Leibold 100% |
This is an act of cultural
genocide and one of the worst human rights abuses of our time. |
44:08 |
Almas Nizamidin 100% |
ALMAS Nizamidin: So I'm
asking government to help me to ask the Chinese government to release my mum,
my wife and bring them to me. |
44:13 |
Nizamidin holds up photo |
Every
day, every day, every single hour. I can't even sleep on the night-time. |
44:23 |
Almas Nizamidin 100% |
That's
my life now. There's not any happiness. I can't enjoy anything. |
44:33 |
Sadam holds up photo |
SADAM ABUDUSALAMU
Maybe they're going to take her again, just because of I'm speaking out. |
44:44 |
Sadam 100% |
I've
got no other option left. I've done everything. I speak with the Home
Affairs. I speak with the foreign ministers. I speak with the, trying to talk
with the Chinese authorities, bribe them, but still, there is nothing
happening in past two years. |
44:54 |
Sadam holds photo |
So
now I have to speak out. And
Australians, I think Australians, all Australia needs to know this story. |
45:09 |
|
|
45:21 |
CREDITS
reporter
SOPHIE
MCNEILL
producer
JEANAVIVE
MCGREGOR
researcher
MEREDITH
GRIFFITHS
MICHAEL
WALSH
ECHO
HUI
BANG
XIAO
editor
MICHAEL
NETTLESHIP
additional
editing
JAMES
BRAYE
camera
RON
FOLEY
additional
LOUIE
EROGLU ACS
GREG
ASHMAN
CHRIS
ALBERT
GREG
NELSON
sound
ROB
MACKAY
additional
sound
TONY
HILL
ANDREW
TIMLIN
Richard
McDermott
drone
Neale Maude
satellite
research
NATHAN
RUSER, Australian Strategic Policy Institute
archive
producer
MICHELLE
BADDILEY
designer
Andrew
McKenzie
legal
Jennifer
Arnup
Deborah
Auchinachie
digital
producer
BRIGID
ANDERSEN
digital
designer
GEORGINA
PIPER
social
media producer
TIM
WILFORD
publicity
Paul
Akkermans
promotions
LAURA
MURRAY
sound
mixer
EVAN
HORTON
colourist
SIMON
BRAZZALOTTO
post
production
JAMES
BRAYE
additional
vision
WALL
STREET JOURNAL
FRANCE
24
BBC
BITTER
WINTER
REUTERS
AP
AFP
GETTY
HUMAN
RIGHTS WATCH
map
data
PLANET
LABS, INC
Google,
DigitalGlobe
theme
music
RICK
TURK
titles
LODI
KRAMER
program
assistant
LYDIA
CHU
production
manager
WENDY
PURCHASE
supervising
producer
MORAG
RAMSAY
executive
producer
SALLY
NEIGHBOUR
abc.net.au/4corners
Australian
Broadcasting Corporation
© 2019