Malcolm
Brabant:
Graduation at St. Andrews,
Scotland's most venerable university. It's the moment when students reach
life's launchpad. In this election, many Scots are also hoping for lift off.
Brad Mackay:
It's not overstated when people say
that this is a historic election.
Malcolm
Brabant:
Brad Mackay is a Professor of
Strategic Management and Vice Principal of St. Andrews.
Brad Mackay:
The outcome of this election is
going to have a massive impact on the future of Scotland, on the future of the
rest of the UK, indeed on the future of the EU for many, many years to come.
Nicola
Sturgeon:
And we are gathered here for one
simple purpose. And that purpose is to demand the right to choose a better
future for our country.
Malcolm
Brabant:
The issue of Britain leaving the
European Union has been incredibly divisive, and some experts believe that the
emotional wounds may take more than a generation to heal. And fear Brexit that
itself could ultimately lead to the break
up of the United Kingdom. Here in Scotland more than anywhere
else this election is being framed in terms of a battle between independence
and staying in the United Kingdom.
Malcolm
Brabant:
The Scottish National Party, the SNP
wants to secure a second independence referendum, to determine whether the
country should leave the UK and become an independent state. The party lost the
first referendum in 2014.
Malcolm
Brabant:
In order to have a chance of a
second bite at independence, the Nationalists and other opposition parties need
to muster enough Parliamentary seats together to defeat Prime Minister Boris
Johnson's Conservatives. The SNP is desperate for Scotland to stay in the EU.
Nicola Sturgeon is the First Minister of Scotland's semi-autonomous Government.
Nicola
Sturgeon:
A vote for the SNP on December the
12th is a vote to escape Brexit. It is a vote to put Scotland's future in
Scotland's hands.
Malcolm
Brabant:
But if the conservatives win a clear
majority, Brexit will go ahead, Scotland will remain in the UK, and dreams of
independence will have to be put on ice for years because the Conservatives
won't allow a second referendum. Stephen Kerr is defending the Parliamentary
district of Stirling, which he won in 2017. He represents the Conservative
Party, which opposes Scottish independence.
Stephen
Kerr:
Why would you break up the most
successful political union in the history of the world? Why would you break up
the United Kingdom family? For what purpose other than some ideological
obsession which frankly has no basis in reality.
Malcolm
Brabant:
800 years ago
when the Scots were at war with the English, and led by King Robert the Bruce,
the military wisdom of the day was: control Stirling, and you control Scotland.
Today the Parliamentary seat has a similar strategic significance. This is a
seat the Conservatives have to win. Last time around
they had a wafer thin majority. Their only realistic
opponents are the Nationalists, the SNP.
Stephen
Kerr:
This is how the seat will be won. It
is going to be won vote by vote and that means a lot of time spent on doorsteps
having conversations with people.
Voter:
No, I am afraid I am going to vote
for your worst enemy.
Steve Kerr:
My worst enemy? I don't have a worst
enemy.
Voter:
Well, you know who. I am for
Scottish Independence. Maybe more the heart.
Steve Kerr:
If you had said to me that you were
going to vote for me I would have done a jig down this
road.
Malcolm
Brabant:
Undaunted, Kerr goes in pursuit of
other potential supporters.
Stephen
Kerr:
We are certainly not going to be
wiped out in Scotland. I mean that's a narrative, the
SNP have a narrative they wish to plant in people's minds.
Malcolm
Brabant:
Alyn Smith is the SNP candidate opposing
Stephen Kerr in Stirling
Alyn Smith:
There is no good news in Brexit.
It's all shades of bad and that is why I want to go to the House of Commons and
to meet these points and try to win these arguments. The UK is not one state.The UK is four countries
that comprise a state. And the trouble being that some of the people who are in charge of the UK right now have never actually taken
the time to understand what our perspective actually is.
Malcolm
Brabant:
That perspective is laid out in an
SNP campaign video.
SNP Election
Video:
Right now, Scotland is being dragged
out of Europe against our will. It's a Brexit we never voted for. Forced on us
by a Tory government we never voted for. A government led by a Prime Minister
whose priorities are not ours.
Malcolm
Brabant:
That prime minister of course is
Boris Johnson, who opposes a second vote on Brexit, as well as a second vote on
Scottish independence.
Boris
Johnson:
Do we want another referendum?
That's why this manifest is so aptly, so aptly named. We don't want another
referendum on Scotland. We don't. And we rule it out because we don't want to
destroy the most successful political partnership of the last 300 years.
Malcolm Brabant:
Boris Johnson's core message is to
get Brexit done, to honor the outcome of the 2016 referendum on European Union
membership. Early in the Scottish campaign, he toured a distillery making
Scotland's national tipple, buoyed by the Bank of England's assessment that his
proposed Brexit deal with Europe would ease economic uncertainty.
Boris
Johnson:
What the Governor of the Bank of
England said quite rightly, is that when we get Brexit done it will immediately
unleash investment and confidence into the UK economy, and that is what I am
saying to people.
Malcolm
Brabant:
Scotland used to be the fiefdom of
the Labour Party. Its leader Jeremy Corbyn is
promising the most radical socialist programme in
generations. The nationalists say a coalition with Labour
is possible if Corbyn guarantees a second referendum on Scottish independence.
But Corbyn says if elected, he won't agree to that, at least not right away.
Jeremy
Corbyn:
No referendum in the first term of a
Labour government because I think we need to
concentrate completely on investment across Scotland. The issue is the needs of
the people of Scotland, and a Labour government in
Westminster would be in a position to deliver that.
Malcolm
Brabant:
But most pollsters agree that if any
party is going to be buried in Scotland on election day, it is Labour. Analyst Mark Diffley says
the nationalists have replaced Labour as the party of
Scotland's working class. He's been studying the ratings of Johnson, Corbyn,
and Scottish first minister Sturgeon.
Mark Diffley:
The Prime Minister is particularly
unpopular in Scotland. He has a satisfaction rating of something like minus 60
or minus 70. Mr Corbyn has about the same, whereas
the First Minister's tends to split the public down the middle.
Malcolm
Brabant:
Back at St. Andrews, Brexit is
causing anxiety. The university worries about attracting the best international
talent, and of losing European grants for research projects. The Vice Principal
says Scottish entrepreneurs doubt the Prime Minister's Brexit confidence.
Brad Mackay:
Well, Scottish business is very
concerned. The EU is a huge export market for Scottish businesses.But
also when you think about supply chains which are integrated across the UK and
the EU and you think about attracting even skilled labour
and different types of labour for businesses, it's of
tremendous concern.
Malcolm
Brabant:
Pro Scottish-Independence Historian
Lesley Orr says England is responsible for creating barriers, particularly the
faction supporting more restrictive immigration policies.
Lesley Orr:
Scotland's aspiration is to be a
progressive outward-looking, inclusive nation kind of rooted in civic
nationalism and actually one of the issues that Scotland has that diverges from
England is the hostile environment that is the current government policy that
is doing its best to keep people out, to exclude people.
Malcolm
Brabant:
Polls show that young people are
driving the independence movement, but entrepreneur Harry Turner is going
against the tide. He's hesitant about investing more in his catering business
because of economic uncertainty. In this election, his vote will go to a party
that opposes Scottish independence.
Harry
Turner:
Personally I think that if Scotland went
independent I would move to England because I am that worried about the economic
situation.
Malcolm
Brabant:
Such views are music to the
conservatives. Pollster Mark Diffley.
Mark Diffley:
In terms of the outcome on December
13th, the Conservatives may do slightly better than one may have predicted a
little while ago.
Malcolm
Brabant:
In Stirling, voter John Macmillan
has no time for Scottish independence.
John
Macmillan:
It would be a ridiculous thing to
do. It wouldn't, emotionally, it would satisfy some people but sensibly it's absolutely ludicrous and I very much hope that we won't be
given the opportunity to have yet another referendum. Referendums are supposed
to make decisions. We made a decision last time and
that is the way it should stay.
Douglas
MacLachlan:
It's just so hard, so many people
want the best for Scotland and yet we can't get it because we are overruled by
England.
Scottish
Election Video:
Now is the time to choose a new path
for scotland.
Malcolm
Brabant:
The SNP's Alyn
Smith hopes that a new path will lead to a winning alliance with the Labour Party.
Alyn Smith:
We will use that to build common
cause to stop Brexit. We will build common cause to make clear that it's
Scotland's choice to have a referendum and how people want to vote in that referendum
is a wider question.
Malcolm
Brabant:
His opponent Stephen Kerr dreads the
Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn moving into the Prime
Minister's official residence in London.
Stephen
Kerr:
That man should be nowhere near
Number Ten Downing Street. Almost within weeks our country would be in a
financial crisis as confidence seeped away, as capital fled the country because
the manifesto that Labour are standing on is a
Venezuelan recipe.
Malcolm
Brabant:
This has been the most bitter election in decades. The next government will need to build bridges. Because of Brexit, that may be impossible.
|
TIMECODE |
LOWER
THIRD |
1 |
|
|
2 |
|
|
3 |
|
|
4 |
|
|
5 |
|
|
6 |
|
|
7 |
|
|
8 |
|
|
9 |
|
|
10 |
|
|
11 |
|
|
12 |
|
|
13 |
|
|